Hello Rachel Maddow, MSNBC, USA Today, CNN, Washington Post, Slate: Another Major Russia Story Falls Apart

The biggest purveyors of  “fake news” and irresponsible journalism are the news media outlets complaining most about it.

MSNBC’s Rachel Maddow is at the forefront of the latest fake news on Russia.

Maddow’s Rant

DHS didn’t bother to tell the 21 states Russia tried to hack during the election until this afternoon. https://t.co/48CNZL8MBp

— Maddow Blog (@MaddowBlog) September 23, 2017

The story went viral of course.

https://twitter.com/JaynePart/status/911404886717218816

The same day @realDonaldTrump refers to “Russia Hoax,” Homeland Security Dept. tells 21 states that Russia tried to hack their elections. https://t.co/X6UrqFMUTW

— Rep. Don Beyer (@RepDonBeyer) September 22, 2017

Another Story Falls Apart

Today, Glen Greenwald reports Yet Another Major Russia Story Falls Apart. Is Skepticism Permissible Yet?

LAST FRIDAY, most major media outlets touted a major story about Russian attempts to hack into U.S. voting systems, based exclusively on claims made by the Department of Homeland Security. “Russians attempted to hack elections systems in 21 states in the run-up to last year’s presidential election, officials said Friday,” began the USA Today story, similar to how most other outlets presented this extraordinary claim.

MSNBC’s Paul Revere for all matters relating to the Kremlin take-over, Rachel Maddow, was indignant that this wasn’t told to us earlier and that we still aren’t getting all the details. “What we have now figured out,” Maddow gravely intoned as she showed the multi-colored maps she made, is that “Homeland Security knew at least by June that 21 states had been targeted by Russian hackers during the election. . .targeting their election infrastructure.”

So what was wrong with this story? Just one small thing: it was false. The story began to fall apart yesterday when the Associated Press reported that Wisconsin – one of the states included in the original report that, for obvious reasons, caused the most excitement – did not, in fact, have its election systems targeted by Russian hackers.

The spokesman for Homeland Security then tried to walk back that reversal, insisting that there was still evidence that some computer networks had been targeted, but could not say that they had anything to do with elections or voting.

Then the story collapsed completely last night. The Secretary of State for another one of the named states, California, issued a scathing statement repudiating the claimed report:

This has happened over and over and over again. Inflammatory claims about Russia get mindlessly hyped by media outlets, almost always based on nothing more than evidence-free claims from government officials, only to collapse under the slightest scrutiny, because they are entirely lacking in evidence.

The examples of such debacles when it comes to claims about Russia are too numerous to comprehensively chronicle. I wrote about this phenomenon many times and listed many of the examples, the last time in June when 3 CNN journalists “resigned” over a completely false story linking Trump adviser Anthony Scaramucci to investigations into a Russian investment fund which the network was forced to retract.

Remember that time the Washington Post claimed that Russia had hacked the U.S. electricity grid, causing politicians to denounce Putin for trying to deny heat to Americans in winter, only to have to issue multiple retractions because none of that ever happened? Or the time that the Post had to publish a massive editor’s note after its reporters made claims about Russian infiltration of the internet and spreading of “Fake News” based on an anonymous group’s McCarthyite blacklist that counted sites like the Drudge Report and various left-wing outlets as Kremlin agents?

Or that time when Slate claimed that Trump had created a secret server with a Russian bank, all based on evidence that every other media outlet which looked at it were too embarrassed to get near? Or the time the Guardian was forced to retract its report by Ben Jacobs – which went viral – that casually asserted that WikiLeaks has a long relationship with the Kremlin? Or the time that Fortune retracted suggestions that RT had hacked into and taken over C-SPAN’s network? And then there’s the huge market that was created – led by leading Democrats – that blindly ingested every conspiratorial, unhinged claim about Russia churned out by an army of crazed conspiracists such as Louise Mensch and Claude “TrueFactsStated” Taylor?

And now we have the Russia-hacked-the-voting-systems-of-21-states to add to this trash heap. Each time the stories go viral; each time they further shape the narrative; each time those who spread them say little to nothing when it is debunked.

Regardless of your views on Russia, Trump and the rest, nobody can possibly regard this climate as healthy. Just look at how many major, incredibly inflammatory stories, from major media outlets, have collapsed. Is it not clear that there is something very wrong with how we are discussing and reporting on relations between these two nuclear-armed powers?

Hello Rachel Maddow!

https://twitter.com/stacyherbert/status/913253366234365952

https://twitter.com/stacyherbert/status/913256158969839616

🧐I knew then Russia was jacking w/ our election. I think I told u. Rachel’s just doing her job. Just like u r. It’s #IdeologicalSubversion.😏 pic.twitter.com/yecRqvKMiY

— Official ©Marv 🧐🤠👽🕵️🤡😏™ (@MarvinAmelie) September 28, 2017

https://twitter.com/stacyherbert/status/913256758788763648

https://twitter.com/stacyherbert/status/913254955712004096

https://twitter.com/maxkeiser/status/913258053872402433

My Quick Take

People listen to nonsense from @maddow and believe it. The correct approach is to treat it as comedy. https://t.co/KeXxbmH1vI

— Mike “Mish” Shedlock (@MishGEA) September 28, 2017

The worst aspect, missed by @ggreenwald is Homeland Security purposely spreads fake Russia news to bring down Trump.https://t.co/KeXxbmH1vI

— Mike “Mish” Shedlock (@MishGEA) September 28, 2017

Mike “Mish” Shedlock