On Friday, president Trump invoked the Defense Production Act and Ordered General Motors to Make Ventilators.
President Trump ordered General Motors Co. to sharply ramp up the production of ventilators to treat coronavirus patients, turning to a wartime presidential power that he had been reluctant to use.
Mr. Trump on Friday invoked the Defense Production Act, or DPA, which dates back to the Korean War and gives the president powers to require businesses to produce goods tied to national defense. For weeks he had said that the threat of invoking the DPA was sufficient. Previously he likened using the DPA to nationalizing American business. He reversed course Friday, saying GM was “wasting time” in negotiations with the federal government.
With the number of confirmed cases of Covid-19—the disease caused by the new coronavirus—topping 100,000 in the U.S. on Friday, worries about a ventilator shortage have grown all the more urgent.
GM was already working toward wide-scale ventilator production through a collaboration struck last week with medical-device firm Ventec Life Systems.
Trump Blames GM for “Stupidly” Causing Ventilator Shortage
Earlier today I commented Trump Blames GM for “Stupidly” Causing Ventilator Shortage
Big Foot In Big Mouth Disease
GM replied to Trump, “Ventec, GM and our supply base have been working around the clock for over a week to meet this urgent need.”
Not only was GM already working on the problem, this is not a matter of snapping one’s fingers and demanding a certain number of ventilators.
GM needs to retool production lines. GM needs FDA approved parts.
Once again Trump stuck his big foot into his big mouth.
Mike “Mish” Shedlock



Well this is ultimately the price of running a disease model healthcare system.
I just heard this on Twitter. Supposedly in 10 days, the CDC will recommend everyone to wear a mask.
ROFL.
We are way behind the curve on that. If every person is wearing a mask, that means that every sick person is wearing a mask, and that in turn means the virus can not be spread by droplets. That, in my opinion, is why the spread in Asia is so much lower than anywhere else. It is not unusual for them to wear a mask due to pollution, allergies etc, so for them to go to everyone wearing a mask was not a big step.
Now we need to ramp up production of masks. Heck, my company has a few sewing machines, and people with nothing to do. We couldn’t make hundreds a day, but we could make dozens a day.
We are way more behind than that. There’s a commenter here who’s a “pulmonary expert” and he thinks masks are useless. ROFL.
This country is really amusing.
Wearing masks as a protection from getting infected is only a minor help, since you can get infected via your eyes, anyway, and since they only block 95% of the viruses, even if worn correctly. Having infected people wear a mask is essential.
Hospitals have been running lean for a very long time. That’s the corporate model. It’s a just-in-time-model. Hospital in-patient capacity has been driven low, because that’s the most profitable model. Come on people, get with the program. There are so many worthless “wellness programs” around, that we don’t need the heavy-guns hospital capacity. Final expenses insurance is on a roll! I’m signing up now! U 2
Around the time the first round of sanctions were introduced, it turned out, the biggest applicant for waivers was a company that imported components from China. The company stated; noone has produced a single transformer in NA in the last 20 years.
Take that in…
All of the Donald DF Trump-defenders handily ignore the fact that CV was ignored for months despite warnings from many people and organizations.
Today, weeks into the peak uproar about ventilators, he panics.
The time for leaders worldwide to have panicked was 2003, after the last Chinese Horseshoe coronavirus jumped from a civet to humans. That one was labelled SARS, and promptly forgotten by 2005 when government research grants were cancelled en mass and switched to…how an atmospheric trace gas could be variously predicted and projected to accomplish what the next coronavirus is now, in fact, doing. Our current crisis is entirely because, after 17 years of fair warning, there was still no alert system in place to help the doctor who died trying to blow the whistle on the damned thing.
I’m daily more convinced I have the answer to the Fermi Paradox: Unwarranted optimism in the face of viruses. It’s a fortunate accident that this one isn’t killing at the rate of Ebola, 3X smallpox.
All any of this shows is the vast majority of leaders are REDUNDANT except perhaps for Putin and whoever runs Singapore.
Precisely why capitalism and human well-being are sometimes at odds …
For years, Raoult has been pleading for a drastic revision of health economic models, so the treatments, cure and therapies created mostly during the 20th century, are considered a patrimony in the service of all humanity.“That’s not the case”, he says, “because we abandon medicine that is not profitable, even if it’s effective. That’s why almost no antibiotics are manufactured in the West.”
“we abandon medicine that is not profitable, even if it’s effective”
When profit becomes the be-all and end-all for every endeavor, that too often results in more harm than good for too many people.
Antibiotic use ( overuse?), is greater now than ever. Hardy abandoned.
If, as it seems, “patrimony” refers to limiting excessive “IP rights” “bans” on producing stuff, in order to extract usury rent from what is now commodities, no doubt the guy is right.
Pharma is probably THE poster child for an industry which does benefit from a robust IP framework (as long as regulators insist on massively expensive trials before allowing product to be sold), but even there, IP laws are being abused to where Pharmacos spend more money defending ancient “patents” and twiddling around with whether something is “patentable”, than on creating new product which works as efficiently as possible.
The only alternative to capitalism (voluntary relations between thinking individuals) is statism (rule by guns). It is only by failure to essentialize that people desire the latter — as if freely thinking individuals were dangerous/evil, but guns were practical and just.
False dichotomy … and when freely thinking individuals (or phony pretend “persons” known as corporations) are psychopaths, they can do nearly as much damage with capitalism as with guns … or both … corporatism is another form of statism, known as fascism.
Edit is working again for me, Mish. First time in several days, though. Take this note to software support and tell them I said it’s the worst monitoring I’ve seen since the pigs ate Granny at the family reunion.
Several guys have complained for several days now, seems ok at present.
Why France is hiding a cheap and tested virus cure
The French government is arguably helping Big Pharma profit from the Covid-19 pandemic https://asiatimes.com/2020/03/why-france-is-hiding-a-cheap-and-tested-virus-cure/
10% of people still died or did not recover with the medicine. Without the medicine about 90% of people still recover. The study actually says the medicine doesnt work.
University of Nebraska study finds Covid-19 can be transmitted through the air without droplets.
Do you have a link for that study?
@MishTalk you and your tribe have gone full LOF.
You used to be skeptical of pronouncements by company executives, now you lap them up like a lemming.
And what is GM?
Oh yea, a company, unlike Ford, that was so F’d up it needed the taxpayers to buy it to save the jobs of union workers… another angelic bunch.
Junior caught a cold and murdered grandma
New world order
TRUMPTOAST
It’s what’s for breakfast
Why GM? Why not GE Healthcare?
One, two, many…..
GM, Ford, others…..
It’s not like there is a huge demand for cars right now, or in the near future…
Cause GE Healthcare is in the healthcare business. Think like Trump man!
Wait a minute now…
According to a few posters here, all Trump needed to do was “order them to do it” and it would be done.
They made it sound like everyone was sitting around just waiting for Trump to give the order.
Now he gives the order and we find out they were already working on it?
Well damn – that’s gonna be a huge shock and disappointment to some people.
Projecting out a week, New York, New Jersey, Mass, Louisiana, and Michigan will all be over capacity. Washington, Florida, Indiana, Pennsylvania, Colorado, DC and Connecticut will be approaching it. My guess for end of month is 208k cases and 4800 deaths, and by April 3, a week from now, 404k cases and 13k deaths, and by April 7th this will pass the annual flu in deaths, with more deaths in 2 months than the annual flu had in it’s 15 month run.
My math agrees.
Get with the program. “This is just a flu”.
In the end, this will end up with GM/Ford importing said ventilators from China.
Just take a look at what Elon Musk did. “Tesla’s going to make ventilators” –> Ended up getting them from China.
This is what “winning” looks like in the age of Coronavirus.
which is WHY WE NEED TO BRING BACK more supply chain to merica
JIT was always a failure and meant only to enrich 1%
started with NAFTA and WTO – total living wage give away
we’re ready to setup several companies to supply them using robotics and high tech workers(that get paid living wages)
When you outsourced your supply chain, that’s the most logical thing to do when you’re in a pinch. GM can probably do assembly from parts from China.
Now, WHO and WHY did the supply chain got outsourced to China?
WHO: Americans.
WHY: Greed
Don’t worry, the same cycle will happen in China
WHO: Chinese
WHY: Greed
Same shit everywhere. Remember, in order to be RiCH, X – Y >>>>> 0, and in order to do that Y has to be really really small. Just basic math there.
China doesn’t have Wall Street whipping the behinds of every exec to maximize profits. It might have an equivalent of Japan, where the top execs make a pittance compared to their American peers. That is the who and why.
And Wall Street is only in a position to whip anyone, because The Fed handed them, in exchange for nothing, all the wealth other people spent generations building up.
American “leaders” don’t just happen to be universally stupid, mediocre and unable to look more than a quarter ahead, because they are American.
There’s nothing wrong with Americans simply on account of them being Americans. Rather, the wrong is the existence of a Central Bank. Financialization. A government powerful enough to rob others to bail out anybody, for any reason (which is just another way of spelling “a government which WILL bail out those with the resources to lobby it, with money stolen from those without).
The wrong lies with the ability to “make money” from a house, as it, obvious to all and anyone literate, sits there literally decaying (and, like a cellphone, becoming more outdated) as time goes by.
With the ability to “make money” by randomly owning stocks, bonds, funds and other instruments of crass theft obfuscation one has no asymmetric insight into how will perform (as in, one don’t work there and aren’t directly involved in operations.).
With the ability to make money not by selling something of value to an audience free to not buy if they don’t like the price/performance, but instead by getting ambulance chasers to abuse courts to simply take the money from others.
Etc., etc. All of the above, exists solely to prop up a rentier class of completely useless leeches, which add no value nor benefit to anything nor anyone at all, beside their own leeching selves.
Once the above is how you make money, Americans will do the above. Everyone would. Even in Sweden, which at one point were perhaps more smitten by Olof Palme’s idealism than most, the ruling clique are now, on account of their own central bank, busier coming up with excuses for why other people should not be allowed to build a roof over their heads in a cold winter, than in building anything of value.
The only reason the Sandersites of the world seem to think Swedes are somehow “better people” than Americans, is that our Fed is and government is, and has been for longer, more powerful on account of reserve currency status etc., hence even better at stealing on behalf of the rentier class, than theirs.
I don’t bust out The Rand too much anymore, but after reading that, I couldn’t resist…
“When you see that in order to produce, you need to obtain permission from men who produce nothing – When you see that money is flowing to those who deal, not in goods, but in favors – When you see that men get richer by graft and by pull than by work, and your laws don’t protect you against them, but protect them against you – When you see corruption being rewarded and honesty becoming a self-sacrifice – You may know that your society is doomed.”
Well, Rand didn’t think about negative externalities when she wrote that overrated. book. If you produce pollution which most industries do, then it’s totally good that men who produce none of those things are put in charge.
Atlas Shrugged: a book for simple brains.
Haha, consumption without production and problem solved.
“If you produce pollution which most industries do, then it’s totally good that men who produce none of those things are put in charge.”
No, it’s not. Producing nothing at all, instead sitting there robbing others until they’re starving to death, since that is the only way your incompetent self is able to feed yourself, is a heck of a lot more destructive than some occasional, temporary unanticipated algae growth from fertilizer runnoff.
Doesn’t mean you can’t have rules against externalities. Truly free societies, pure anarchies, have those protections against negative externalities built in. Simply by way of everyone whose drinking water you pollute, being in a position to blow you away without consequence, should you choose to do so. Try to dam or divert a river upstream of a Taliban village which relies on it for sustenance, and you’ll realize you don’t need totalitarian government to sort out negative externalities…
But assuming you’re not quite cut from Taliban cloth, hence insist on dismantling freedom’s, and nature’s, built in protections against negative externalities: Those you want in charge, are those competent enough to produce something of value, since being able to do so, is a prerequisite for being able to make realistic cost/benefit tradeoffs between different ways, as well as whether at all, to produce any given valuable something. People who are too incompetent to produce anything at all, will never be able to make that determination. As they don’t even know how anything valuable is produced. Much less various potential side effects, as well as various possible ways of ameliorating them.
All of that, takes some semblance of understanding of something useful. Not just sitting there screeching “me, me, me” while cheering on the money printers and jackboots to debase and coerce everyone else, on the clique of clueless, incompetent screechers’ behalf.
In America, all the way until well past WW2, most (not all, you’d have to go back another 75-100 years for that..) people in decision making positions in the US, achieved their positions on the back of some demonstrated competence. But since then, a completely run amuck Fed, as well as all manners of completely unconstrained “legal” activism and an ever growing state, have resulted in competent people being pushed aside by FIRE halfwits and ambulance chasers. None of whom are, as you’d think even the most hopelessly illiterate and indoctrinated would realize by now, even remotely as competent at managing anything in a useful fashion, as a bunch of polluting communists have proven to be.
Yeah they do. Indirectly. Wall St whips American execs, who in turns whips their suppliers in China, who in turns whips A,B,C, etc. The world is interconnected remember?
Yeah, we see how well that’s working out for us…
Those who “produce pollution” are being bailed out to the tune of TRILLIONS by those who produce nothing.
Not shocking at all when you consider the same non-producers have been protecting the same polluters for decades.
As always, people get the government they deserve…
In a world where everything has a pro and con, the notion of progress is ultimately a delusion.
You can’t have better worlds, only different ones.
Edit still isn’t working, so I’ll make my other point that The Donald is equally responsible for this GM PR F**k up by not knowing enough from personal lack in high tech manufacturing experience to simply ask an aide, “Would you check with GM that this guy wasn’t just blowing smoke up my ass commiting 40,000 units? That seems like a steep ramp for a techie gadget to me.” Edit test.
Didn’t the Donald claim that he had enough intelligence to be a scientist or some such?
He thinks that things run according to his timeline. The virus will end by Easter. GM will make thousands of ventilators by day X.
But does it matter? His approval is up. It’s probably a good thing, this thing will end up affecting his base most of all.
In what way is edit not working
I already reported it about a week ago. Blank screen. Prior to that, it worked.
Scroll not blocking on Android anymore it seems. Must have been the cookie notice because now that shows.
I would think that by the time these products are in actual production there won’t be a need anymore. Sounds like the commie command and control economic model. The question is wether the threat will be resolved by then and can we then export these surplus vents to other countries that need them.
It didn’t work for me for a while, but then it started to work again. Server was
probably overwhelmed.
Perhaps Trump was attempting to broaden his base by appealing to the “bigger the government, the better” crowd. Of course, he looked like a fool doing it since the position is foolish.
and yet his ratings are going up up up
I haven’t tracked down who “committed” 40,000 units, or when, within GM, but this screams GM Public Relations slick F**k up. It’s easy to blithely assume command of infinite corporate resources to some worthy goal and offhandedly commit to a totally ludicrous goal, especially if you’ve never spent a minute in the product design and advanced manufacturing or quality trenches.
It’s entirely another to know enough to run the risk of shipping a shitty ventilator to a hospital which might fail at 2:7 a.m. and kill some poor soul…and prevent it happening. Good on whoever stopped the goat rodeo before someone was killed.
If my ventilator has to keep me alive for 30 days, I insist on a Honda.
I have to assume Mish has never held a supervisorial position and gotten a lot of ‘guff’ back from an underling when he needs an important but unpleasant task done. Either that or his hatred of Donald Trump is due to some ethno-racial hatred that does not allow him to see the problem.
Are you seriously wondering out loud whether Mish has a racial or ethnic bias against Trump? WTF is wrong with you?
well truth hurts tengen
now go self quarantine and stay off comments – only make your TDS worse
Maybe because the world is filled with competent people that the failures of Trump are so apparent. I wonder who your world is filled with….
Trump knows who’s responsible: https://i.pinimg.com/236x/99/84/99/998499b5e81a65411e60261e141cc6a7–family-circus-cartoon-comic-character.jpg
He’s panicked now….100,000 cases—the worst in the world. Someone asked him to multiply that by 2 and told him that that would be the count in the next week.
OHHHH…he said…you mean there will be more cases?
Deflect, deflect, deflect…..
TDS got you down
then just self quarantine
instead of typical crap out of your mouth
unfortunately 2X is optimistic with the doubling rate in the US (3 days).
By the end of next week it’ll be 400K. You guys stand to pass 1M within a fortnight. The only thing now that stands to limit the growth is testing capacity.
The peak doesn’t happen till 3 weeks after a Country wide total shutdown.
Best of luck
Mister Metokur Live – Month Three and Counting
seems GM is like NANCY the pelosi – just another DIMWIT of DNC or stupid
take our pick