The latest GDPNow forecast is 2.8% down from 3.5% on the March 1 ISM spike.

Once again an ISM spike was mostly taken back. The ISM spike on February 1 was taken back the next day.

From Pat Higgins, creator of GDPNow, on today's forecast.

The GDPNow model estimate for real GDP growth (seasonally adjusted annual rate) in the first quarter of 2018 is 2.8 percent on March 7, down from 3.5 percent on March 1. The nowcasts of first-quarter real consumer spending growth and first-quarter real nonresidential equipment investment growth declined from 2.9 percent and 10.1 percent, respectively, to 2.6 percent and 6.9 percent, respectively, after the light vehicle sales release from the U.S. Bureau of Economic Analysis on March 2. The nowcast of the contribution of net exports to first-quarter real GDP growth declined from -0.43 percentage points to -0.59 percentage points after this morning's international trade release from the U.S. Census Bureau.

ISM Discussion

I exchanged emails with Pat Higgins late last week and on Monday this week and wrote about it yesterday in GDPNow-ISM Dynamics: Email Discussion With Pat Higgins.

The discussion centered around dynamic factors for ISM. Here is a chart of actual vs. theoretical had GDPNow not increased the dynamic factors for March 1.

PCE Estimates With and Without ISM Factor Changes

Image placeholder title

The final estimate is a bit more complex than just changing the factors. Yet one can see that had it not been for a change in the factors, there would not have been another ISM spike.

Justification

RECOMMENDED ARTICLES

I asked Higgins "Is there some justification to do use the factors from Feb 27?"

He responded: The justification is that the factor values in the February 27th file do not incorporate the data in the March 1 ISM release, or any of the other released February data like Consumer Sentiment, while the factor values in the March 1 file at https://www.frbatlanta.org/-/media/documents/cqer/researchcq/gdpnow/GDPTrackingModelDataAndForecasts.xlsx do incorporate the February data. So you can get a sense of how the ISM, and other February data, is influencing the estimates of the factor values."

ISM Discussion With Jim Bianco

I had lunch a couple weeks ago with Jim Bianco, head of Bianco research. He talked about survivor bias and how it has impacted ISM surveys.

I wrote about that discussion in ISM a Leading Indicator? Of What?

Here is a brief synopsis:

  • Since 2007, ISM membership has declined by about 33%. The companies that remain display a survivor bias. They made it through the great recession intact. And they tend to be more bullish.
  • Jim mentioned a Fed study that came to the same conclusion. The regional manufacturing surveys all have the same flaw.
  • Jim also mentioned that his firm gets polled in the ISM Nonmanufacturing survey. He has a handful of employees.
  • His firm has the same weight in the survey as Walmart which may be hiring or firing thousands of employees. I have mentioned this idea before, but now I have a concrete example to provide.

​ISM has not been a reliable indicator of anything for quite some time. All of the diffusion reports from the Fed regions suffer similar flaws.

It strongly appears that ISM is influencing the GDPNow model factors in a predictable and wrong way.

Mike "Mish" Shedlock

GDPNow-ISM Dynamics: Email Discussion With Pat Higgins

On Feb 1, the GDPNow forecast surged to 5.4% on ISM. It did so again last week. I discussed the setup with Pat Higgins.

Pat Higgins Explains the Wild 5.4% GDPNow Forecast Made February 1

The GDPNow model forecast jumped to 5.4% on February 1, only to come crashing down the next day.

GDPNow ISM Bounce Fades: Forecast Dips to 3.8%, Nowcast Remains 2.8%

Volatility remains the name of the game for GDPNow. Nonvolatility is the game for the New York Fed Nowcast.

GDPNow Forecast Sinks on ISM and Construction Reports

The GDPNow forecast fell to 1.7% on September 3 following weak construction and ISM reports.

GDPNow and Nowcast Head in Opposite Directions on Trade Data: Pot Shot Coming Up

The latest GDPNow forecast was on Feb 6 and Nowcast was on Feb 8. The reaction to the same trade release is interesting.

GDPNow: Another Plunge Coming?

Ther initial GDPNow forecast for the second-quarter GDP was 4.3% on May 1. On May 4, the forecast was 4.2%.

Another Recession Warning: ISM Contracts 4th Month

ISM fired another recession warning today as the manufacturing contraction extends another month.

Another ISM/PMI Divergence: Non-Manufacturing

On April 3, I noted a huge discrepancy between the ISM manufacturing report and Markit’s PMI manufacturing report.

Email From Pat Higgins On the Dynamic Factor Volatility of GDPNow

Following the ISM manufacturing report, the GDPNow model upped its 4th quarter GDP forecast from 2.9% to 4.5%. On Friday, GDPNow revised its forecast to 3.3%. An Email from Pat Higgins, creator of GDPNow explains what happened.