It Only Takes One

Given the 50-50 split in the Senate, it only takes one Democrat defection to kill any piece of legislation if no Republicans play ball. 

Possible Defections

There are three Democrat Senators in the pool of potential defectors.

  1. Joe Manchin, Wet Virginia 
  2. Kyrsten Sinema, Arizona 
  3. Jon Tester, Montana

Minimum Wage Defection Found

The Wall Street Journal reports Manchin doesn't support Biden's $15 minimum wage proposal. 

Manchin proposes the current federal minimum wage of $7.25 should be raised by a smaller amount.

Manchin seeks $11 adjusted for inflation in future years. West Virginia's current minimum wage is $8.75.

Reconciliation Issue

Manchin is not the only problem Biden has with the minimum wage. 

Note that a hike in the minimum wage is not a budget item subject to reconciliation rules.

That means it would take 60 Senators to go along if any Republicans were persistent with a filibuster.

Killing the Filibuster

What about killing the filibuster rule?


That idea does not work because Manchin and possibly other Democrat Senators are against killing the filibuster process. 


Might there be a compromise?

That's possible. The $11 proposal of Manchin could fly or perhaps something a bit higher like the Arizona minimum wage of $12.15.

Possible Republican Defections in Smaller Hike

  • Arkansas Min Wage $11.00
  • Maine Min Wage: $12.15
  • West Virginia Min Wage: $8.75
  • Arizona Min Wage: $12.15

Manchin would go along with $11 or possibly slightly higher. Sue Collins in Maine might easily go along with $12.15. Arkansas is more of a wild card but perhaps Tom Cotton or John Boozman would go along with $11.00. 

There are no Arizona Republican Senators in play (both are Democrats) but $12.15 and seems like a possible target.

My guess is either $11.00 or $12.15 will fly especially if small businesses are exempt. 

The key is avoiding a filibuster. That may take exemptions for small businesses. 

In practice, however, a small business exemption might not mean much. It will be hard for small businesses to attract people at $7.25 if everyone else is paying $11.00 or $12.25.

Related Articles

  1. Biden Makes His First Protectionist Trade Policy Error Already
  2. Climate Change Moves to the Forefront of Biden's Legislation
  3. Is Biden's Easy Money Stimulus Plan Dead or Alive?

Regarding point #3, Manchin is willing to go along with Biden's $1.9 trillion proposal.


Is Biden's Easy Money Stimulus Plan Dead or Alive?

A budget reconciliation process between Democrats and Republicans is underway. Biden is still pushing for a big stimulus deal.

Amazon Ups Minimum Wage to $15 for All Employees Starting Nov 1

Amazon unilaterally upped its minimum wage, even for part-time workers. Now it wants every company to do the same.

Excellent Reflections on Minimum Wage Hikes Backfiring Overseas

Here's an excellent set of Tweets on minimum wages from "Trinh" @Trinhnomics in Hong Kong, on actions taken by S Korea.

Chart of the Day: California Minimum Wage Hike History

California Governor Jerry Brown launched a Political Earthquake proposing a series of minimum wage hikes every year between now and 2022 when the minimum wage hits $15.

Biden's Plan: The Good, the Bad, the Ugly

We have details of Biden's Plan. Let's take a look at 16 items.

Fight for $15: Nineteen States Increase Minimum Wage January 2017

Hello retailers, fast food restaurants, and employers in general. Expect your costs of doing business will soar in 2017.

Did the Battle for Higher Minimum Wages go Into Reverse?

There is a new pushback against minimum wage hikes. With republicans in complete control nationally, odds of meaningful legislation are the national level are slim.