In Largest 5-year cohorts, and Ten most Common Ages in 2017 Calculated Risk noted "The younger baby boom generation dominated in 2010. By 2017 the millennials have taken over. And by 2020, the boomers are off the list."

He concluded "My view is this is positive for both housing and the economy, especially in the 2020s."

Color Coding

To judge that assessment, I took Calculated Risk's table and color coded it.

  • Red: Not Buying
  • Yellow: Likely Cannot Afford to Buy
  • Green: Potential First Time Buyers

2030 is too far away to make an assessment. Too many things can happen. Instead, let's discuss the next five years or so, using the middle column as our guide.


  • There is a favorable shift from cohorts 4-5 to chorts 2-3.
  • The first "not buying" cohort jumps from cohort 7 to cohort 4.
  • There were three "not buying" groups in 2017 but there are four in 2020.
  • There was a favorable shift from "cannot afford" from 2017 to 2020.

On the surface, the demographic trends may appear neutral or slightly favorable. However, I was pretty lenient with the green, potential first-time buyers.


Given housing price trends, most 25-29 cannot afford a house now and unless there is a price crash, those conditions will not change in the next five years.

Also, attitudes towards family formation and mobility have changed.

Finally, as boomers die off, millennials will inherit their parents homes. This will put a supply of homes up for sale, at a clear impact to prices.

For now, and the next five years, attitudes and affordability are the key issues. They far outweigh any potential demographic benefit, if any.

Home Buyer's Dilemma

Please consider Home Buyer's Dilemma Explained in One Picture.

Image placeholder title

The only way that changes in the next five years is is housing crashes. And if that happens, what happens to jobs and wages?

Mike "Mish" Shedlock

Rich Dad’s Demographic Crash Thesis vs. Mish’s “Pain Trade” Thesis

Author and real estate mogul Robert Kiyosaki, better known as “Rich Dad“, is predicting a stock market crash starting in 2016.

Housing Bubble Reblown: Last Chance for a Good Price Was 7 Years Ago

Housing prices have far outstripped wage growth and rental prices. Something has to give. So it will.

Significant Differences in Senate vs House Tax Overhaul Plan: Will Anything Get Done This Year?

There are significant differences between the House and Senate versions of the tax overhaul. Unlike the House, Senate Republicans cannot afford to lose more than two votes. Also unlike the House, the Senat has budget rules that must be met. Will the differences be resolved in reconciliation?

Housing: "Permanently High Plateau" Calls

Calls for a "permanently high plateau" in housing come amidst uncertainty about the market.

Demographics and Destiny: Pension Trainwreck Coming Up

A pension crisis looms as shown by excellent charts from the Harvard Kennedy School and the Peter G. Peterson Foundation

China’s Population Poised to Crash in Perfect Demographic Storm

Those who still have not gotten the message that China’s expected growth rate of 7% is not going to happen are advised to consider the viewpoints of Nicholas Eberstadt who studies demographics for the American Enterprise Institute.

Housing Starts Plunge 22% and It Will Get Worse

Housing starts took a huge dive in March. April rates to be much worse.

Tax Cut Stimulus Mish vs. Krugman: Libertarians Dead Wrong?

Curious Mix: Mainstream media and Libertarians both believe the Trump tax cuts will stimulate the economy. It won't.

Affordable Housing: Meet Amazon's $18,000 "Lillevilla" House with Free Shipping

Amazon is out to make housing affordable. It will eventually succeed.