by Mish

The index shows sixteenth consecutive quarters of positive year-on-year growth. However, house prices are not rising everywhere around the world.

National Index vs. Major Cities

Image placeholder title

Price Divergences

  • On Australia, IMF assessment points out that house price gains have moderated. However, the extent of cooling has varied considerably across cities. The strongest price increases continue to be recorded in Sydney and Melbourne, where underlying demand for housing remains strong. With house prices still rising ahead of income, standard valuation metrics suggest somewhat higher house price overvaluation relative to the previous IMF assessment.
  • On Austria, IMF assessment notes that the cumulative increase in the house price index over 2007–2015 was nearly 40 percent. To a large extent, this increase was driven by price dynamics in Vienna. The OeNB residential price index indicator, which assesses whether prices move in line with fundamental factors, points to an overvaluation of property prices of about 22 percent for Vienna, while prices in the rest of the country appear broadly in line with fundamentals.
  • On Turkey, IMF assessment points out that the housing market exhibits significant variations across cities. Regional variations have been further accentuated by the presence of more than 2.7 million Syrian refugees since March 2011. Cities near the Syrian border, which have absorbed larger masses of Syrian refugees have seen significant rises in local housing prices since 2011, though they have moderated in recent years.

Mish Comments

Figure 1 screams “global bubble” even though some countries did not participate. Australia and Canada are the the center of the bubble along with some countries I was unaware of.

China is also in a massive bubble but that’s not what Figure 2 suggests.

On January 18, Zerohedge reported China Housing Bubble Finally Pops: First Slowdown After 19 Months Of Acceleration.

Here’s an amusing China tale from Bloomberg: China’s Housing Bubble Wobble

Earlier this year, Mr. and Mrs. Cai, a couple from Shanghai, decided to end their marriage. The rationale wasn’t irreconcilable differences or even mild disagreements; rather, it was a property market bubble in China’s financial hub. The pair, who operate a clothing shop, wanted to buy an apartment for 3.5 million yuan ($519,000), adding to a couple of places they already owned. But the local government had begun, among other bubble-fighting measures, to limit purchases by existing property holders. So, in February, the couple divorced. “Why would we worry about divorce? We’ve been married for so long,” says Mr. Cai. (He requested that the couple’s full names be withheld to avoid potential legal difficulties.) “If we don’t buy this apartment, we’ll miss the chance to get rich.”
In the first eight months of 2016, according to data compiled by Bloomberg, average prices for new homes rose 28 percent in Tier 1 cities, which encompass affluent metropolises like Shanghai, and 10 percent in smaller, Tier 2 cities. The boom traces to 2014, when the People’s Bank of China began easing lending requirements and cutting interest rates. The China Securities Regulatory Commission also lifted restrictions on bond and stock sales by developers, helping them raise money for new projects.
Soon, properties were selling for ever-larger sums in government land auctions. By June 2016, China’s 196 listed developers had incurred 3 trillion yuan in debt, up from 1.3 trillion three years before. In many cities a square meter of undeveloped land is worth more than a square meter of a finished home nearby, a situation the Chinese describe as “flour more expensive than bread.”

Mike “Mish” Shedlock

Greenspan Predicts Housing Bust

On May 21st Greenspan all but assured a housing collapse was coming with his statement Stable prices replacing boom

Housing Bubble and Everything Bubble in One Simple Picture

To understand the magnitude of the housing bubbles simply compare the index of wages to the index of prices.

Housing Bubble in Norway

Here is a quick post under the theme “Housing Bubbles Around The World”. This one is from Norway, courtesy of reader Espen Johansen.

Diving Into the CPI: What’s in Your Basket?

The BLS says Consumer Price Inflation rose 0.1% for the month and is up just 0.9% year over year.

Dissecting the Fed-Sponsored Housing Bubble; HPI-CPI Revisited; Real Housing Prices

In the wake of rising housing prices a reader asked if I would revisit my March 2102 article How Far Have Home Prices “Really” Fallen.

Housing Bubble Comparison: US, UK, Canada, Spain, Australia, Japan

The Economist has a fantastic interactive graphic of housing bubbles over time, shown below. It may take a while to load.

Beyond Bubble: $9 Million Vancouver Teardown; Ordinary Houses Sell for $Millions Over Asking Price

There are bubbles, then there are really bubbles. I am at a loss for words how obscenely overpriced the Vancouver housing market has become. Sellers list “low” prices hoping to start a bidding war, and the strategy works.

Leading Economic Indicators (LEI) Unexpectedly Dive Into Negative Territory

The Conference Board's LEI index turned negative in June. The yield curve finally made a negative contribution.

National Crane Index: Still Raining Cranes in Australia Despite Housing Bust

Australia's "crane index" hit a new record high. Expect a major home builder bust along with an accompanying recession.