by Mish

Birth/Death Background

The birth/death model is for the birth and death of businesses, not employees. The BLS assumes there are business startups each month that they do not know about. There are also corporations that go out of businesses and everyone loses their job.

The BLS estimates the number of newly employed and newly unemployed people due specifically to the birth and death of businesses, but only on a seasonally unadjusted basis.

Let’s take a look, with a spotlight on construction employment.

Construction Employment

Image placeholder title

Numbers Not Comparable

Those numbers are not comparable. One set of numbers is seasonally adjusted but the other is not.

Yet, it’s rather curious that 74,000 construction jobs were allegedly created in the last two months at the same time construction lost employment for two consecutive months for the first time since 2012.

Caution!

Evey month in my report on jobs, I write …

Birth Death Model
Starting January 2014, I dropped the Birth/Death Model charts from this report. For those who follow the numbers, I retain this caution: Do not subtract the reported Birth-Death number from the reported headline number. That approach is statistically invalid. Should anything interesting arise in the Birth/Death numbers, I will add the charts back.

Seasonal Adjustment Mess

The problem in untangling this mess is the way the BLS does its calculations.

The BLS applies the non-adjusted birth death numbers to the total non-adjusted numbers, then seasonally adjusts the total.

I cannot tell you how much the birth/death model affected the seasonally-adjusted overall total, nor can anyone else.

Not even the BLS can tell you.

The overall effect of the birth/death numbers on the overall numbers is not as big as it seems. That we can show.

Construction Employment

Image placeholder title

In March, the BLS estimated there were 6,560,000 construction employees.  The BLS estimated another 40,000 due to the birth of new businesses.

Rounding to three decimals, the birth/death adjustment is about 0.610 percentage points of the total number of construction jobs.

Construction Scorecard

  1. Not Seasonally Adjusted, the BLS estimates 6,560,000 construction employees.
  2. Not Seasonally Adjusted, the BLS estimated another 40,000 construction employees due to the birth of new businesses.
  3. After seasonally adjusting everything, the BLS says construction employment went down by 15,000.
  4. Seasonally adjusted, the BLS estimates 6,645,000 construction employees.
  5. Construction employment would have gone down more had the birth/death model not added jobs. By how much, we do not know.

Nonfarm Employment

Image placeholder title

Overall, the BLS says the birth/death model created 224,000 jobs. The BLS estimates nonfarm employment at 144,592,000.

Rounding to three decimals, the percentage of jobs the model added to the overall total is a mere 0.155%.

Turning Points

I do not know how either of those percentages translates to the overall seasonally adjusted numbers (and no one else does either).

Regardless,  I question whether any net construction jobs were genuinely added by the birth of businesses at a time when construction spending was down for the month and construction employment was down two months straight.

If the birth/death model added 0.6% to construction employment when instead it should have subtracted, there may be a meaningful error.

Mike “Mish” Shedlock

University Professor Asks: How Accurate and at What Cost is BLS Data?

Here’s the interesting set of questions from the “Mish Mailbag” summarized as follows: How Accurate and at What Cost is BLS Data? Why isn’t there a private industry alternative?”

Jobs +201,000 vs Employment -423,000: Another BLS Divergence

Nonfarm jobs rose but actual employment fell in two different measures of the BLS July jobs report.

Conversations with New York and Atlanta Fed Senior Economists on Their GDP Models

I had had recent phone and email conversations with senior economists at the New York Fed and Atlanta Fed regarding their GDP forecasts.

US Recession Odds Hit 55% According to Deutsche Bank Model

A Deutsche Bank yield curve model says the odds of a US recession are now 55%. Specifically, the model notes the flattening of the yield curve, something I have mentioned numerous times recently.

BLS Revises Payrolls 501,000 Lower Through March

BLS annual revisions knocked off 501,000 jobs through March. Private jobs fell by 514,000 jobs.

Huge Difference Between GDPNow and Nowcast Models

The Atlanta Fed GDPNow and the New York Fed Nowcast GDP models once again are wildly different.

BLS Business Dynamics Report: Private Sector Job Losses Exceed Gains in 2017 Q3

BLS Business Dynamics Report shows a net loss of private jobs for the third quarter. This has not happened since 2010

Deep Dive Into the BLS Job Revisions: What Really Happened?

The BLS benchmark revisions from March 2019 finally see the light of day, today.

Death Spiral Financing

Last night I talked about Homebuilder Wizardry at SPF in Target Warns and Blames Florida – Lowes Blames Dry Weather