by Mish

I am increasingly confident that its estimate is way too high. Let’s take a look at my reasons starting with the latest GDPNow forecast.

GDPNow Latest forecast: 3.0 percent — July 3, 2017

The GDPNow model forecast for real GDP growth (seasonally adjusted annual rate) in the second quarter of 2017 is 3.0 percent on July 3, up from 2.7 percent on June 30. The forecasts of second-quarter real nonresidential structures and residential investment declined from 1.6 and 2.5 percent to 0.6 and 0.1 percent, respectively, after this morning’s construction spending release from the U.S. Census Bureau. The forecasts of second-quarter real consumer spending and nonresidential equipment investment growth increased from 3.1 and 3.0 percent to 3.5 and 4.7 percent, respectively, after this morning’s Manufacturing ISM Report On Business from the Institute for Supply Management.

Soft Data Silliness

GDPNow, as does the Federal Reserve Bank of New York Nowcast, places way too much faith in soft data reports that are not worth a hoot.

On July 3, I commented ISM vs Markit PMI Divergence Widens Again: Believe Markit.

Had GDPNow been following Markit’s PMI instead of ISM it would not have added 0.3 percentage points to its forecast.

Construction Bump

GDPNow started off its initial forecast on May 1, at an unbelievable 4.3% largely due to huge construction spending revisions for the fisrt quarter.

Although actual hard data never matched that initial forecast, the model only corrected slightly.

Contributions to GDPNow Forecast

Image placeholder title

On May 1, GDPNow estimated Personal Consumption Expenditures (PCE) as adding 2.22 percentage points to second quarter GDP.

Total the numbers horizontally to arrive at the GDP forecast in blue.

Despite poor retail sales figures and terrible auto sales, the GDPNow model actually added to its PCE contribution estimate.


GDPNOw PCE Contribution vs Historical PCE Contribution vs Change in PCE

Image placeholder title

The second quarter of 2017 looks nothing like second quarter of 2016. Retail spending reports have been weak and yesterday we had another weak auto report. Ford and GM sales in June were down four five percent from a year ago and essentially flat from May.

There is no sign of a huge rebound in PCE.

Residential Construction

Image placeholder title

GDPNow has a good track record of estimating residential construction contribution to GDP. Its forecast is headed in the right direction.

However, I have both residential and commercial subtracting from second quarter GDP based on the latest construction spending report. Fred does not have GDPNow’s nonresidential data, so I can offer no chart of historical performance.

Mish Estimate

I have PCE adding 0 to 1.0 percentage points to second quarter GDP. A negative number would not be surprising. I have construction and residential investment subtracting 0.2 percentage points each.

I have construction and residential investment subtracting 0.2 percentage points each.

That would put my estimate 1.8 to 2.8 percentage points lower than GDPNow (a range of 0.2 to 1.2).

I also have considerable doubts about Change in Private Inventories (CIPI) as auto inventories are stacking up at what should be decreasing valuations in my way of thinking.

I suspect the BEA will see things differently. But if CIPI is negative, and my other estimates are correct, we will see negative second quarter GDP.

One more month of data remains, and construction spending can be revised in any direction.

To pick as a single number for now, I will estimate second quarter GDP at 0.8%.

Mike “Mish” Shedlock

Dueling GDP Estimates: GDPNow vs. FRBNY Nowcast

Both the Atlanta Fed GDPNow and the New York Fed Nowcast updated their models today. Let’s take a look at where they stand for second-quarter GDP.

Tracking GDPNow Forecasts vs. Reality: What About that Initial 2nd Quarter Estimate?

On May 1, the GDPNow Model came up with an initial forecast of 4.3% for second quarter GDP.

Nowcast 3rd Quarter GDP Estimate 2%, GDPNow 3.7%

We have two revisions coming for second-quarter GDP estimates even as time rolls on. The third-quarter is already a month over. GDPNow has its first estimate, a whopping 3.7%. The GDPNow estimate is 1.7 percentage points higher than Nowcast.

Six GDP Estimates: ZeroHedge, Mish, GDPNow, Nowcast, ISM, Markit

On Wednesday, I asked a handful of bloggers and economic writers their estimate for first quarter GDP.

GDPNow vs Nowcast: When Will Hurricane Adjustments Take Place?

On Friday, GDPNow and the FRBNY Nowcast both posted third-quarter GDP estimates. GDPNow stands at 3.0%.

1st Quarter GDP Estimates: ZeroHedge, Mish, GDPNow, Nowcast, ISM, Markit

On Friday, April 28, the BEA will release its preliminary estimate for first quarter GDP.

Investigating Curious Anomalies in GDPNow and Nowcast GDP Estimates

As of last Friday, the Atlanta Fed GDFPNow model for the second-quarter GDP stood at 3.4%. In contrast, the FRBNY Nowcast report was 2.2%.

GDPNow 4th Quarter Estimate Sinks to 2.8% from 3.3%: What Happened?

On Dec 19 the GDPNow model estimated fourth-quarter GDP at 3.3%. The forecast is now 2.8%. Let's review the reasons.

Six GDP Estimates (Three Revised Today): ZeroHedge, Mish, GDPNow, Nowcast, ISM, Markit

Tomorrow the BEA will release its advance GDP number for first quarter GDP. I revised my estimate today as did ZeroHedge and GDPNow. The lowest estimate in the group is GDPNow at 0.2%. Here are the numbers starting with GDPNow.