Let's compare that Fantasyland projecting with some hard data.

The Council on Foreign Relations reports 115 Percent of Trump’s China Tariff Revenue Goes to Paying Off Angry Farmers.

“Billions of Dollars are pouring into the coffers of the U.S.A.,” tweeted President Trump last month, “because of the Tariffs being charged to China.”

It would be nice if it were true. But it is, in fact, doubly false.

First, tariffs are not “being charged to China.” They are being charged to American firms importing Chinese goods. As the left-hand bar in the graphic above shows, such firms will pay about $8.4 billion in tariffs on China imports by the end of 2018.

Second, this tariff revenue does not remain in U.S. government “coffers.” As shown in the right-hand bar above, all of it and more is being paid out to American farmers as partial compensation for their losses from Chinese tariff retaliation. The U.S. government has already committed to paying out $1.2 billion more to angry American farmers than it will take in this year from angry American firms.


By launching a trade war with China, therefore, the president has simultaneously raised taxes on U.S. companies and lost the government money. And with the farm constituency critical to his 2020 re-election hopes, the losses are only set to mount going forward.

Tariff Man

Things We Know

  1. Trump is "Tariff Man".
  2. President Trump and Treasury Secretary Mnuchin are Totally Clueless About How Markets Function
  3. Trump does not understand basic math nor concepts like "large amounts". Paying down $21 trillion of debt via tariffs collected at $8 billion per year would take 2,625 years.

Point three presumes that the Treasury actually collected $8 billion in tariffs. The article shows that tariffs on Chinese goods cost $1.2 billion due to farm subsidies.

The administration's plan to a Convene Plunge Protection Team (PPT) is icing on the clueless cake.

Mike "Mish" Shedlock

Exploring Trump's Claim of Using Tariffs to Pay Down $21 Trillion in Debt

Trump claims he will use tariffs to pay down the national debt. Let's explore the idea with pictures.

Paying Down Christmas Debt: How Long Will It Take

Consumers splurged this Christmas. GDP will rise. Hooray. But how long will it take for consumers to pay off their debt?

Trump Claims US Farmers Treated Unfairly Then Uses Strategies That Hurt Farmers

Trump claims US farmers are treated unfairly. So what does he do? Enters trade wars that hurt US farmers.

Trump Tariffs Help Sink US Steel: Investigating a Trump "Big Win"

US Steel wanted Trump to put tariffs on Chinese steel imports. The company is not at all pleased with the results.

Trade War Stupidity: US Chip Makers to Pay Tariffs On Their Own Chips

Trump's trade war with the world shifted into a higher gear today. The US imposed tariffs on China. China retaliated.

More Tariffs on China: "They Better Pay Attention" was the Hamptons Message

Not only did Trump whine about interest rates at the Hamptons fundraiser, he also threatened China.

$250 Trillion in Global Debt: How Can That Be Paid back?

Global debt just topped $250 trillion. Please ponder paying the interest on that, let alone the principal.

Investigating Trump's Trade War Through the Eyes of China

Let's take a look at how China sees the escalation of the trade war as described by the Xinhua News Agency in Beijing.

Trump's Trade War With China: The US is Not Winning

Think trade wars are easy to win? Think again.