by Mish

Econoday PMI

Growth in Markit’s U.S. manufacturing sample is as slow as it has been in 8 months, at 52.7 and little changed from the mid-month flash (52.5) and April (52.8). Growth in this sample peaked in January at 55.0 and has been moving lower as new orders, also at an 8-month low, and employment have slowed. Production is steady at a modest level and the sample, in a sign of caution, continues to work down inventories. Other details include slowing in both input costs and selling prices and weakness in export sales. This report, of all the private manufacturing reports, has been signaling the weakest conditions for a factory sector that opened the year with promise which it has yet to fulfill. Watch for the ISM report coming up at 10:00 a.m. ET this morning.

Econoday ISM

May’s composite of 54.9 doesn’t look that strong but the details are very healthy. New orders keep coming in at a very strong rate (59.5), including for exports (57.5), and backlogs are building (55.0). Production is strong, import orders continue to rise, and deliveries are slowing which are all signs of strength. Employment, at 53.5, is also climbing and at a slightly faster rate than April’s 52.0 in what is a positive indication for manufacturing payrolls in tomorrow’s employment report. In a sign of confidence, ISM’s sample is slowly building inventories of raw materials while the assessment of finished inventories is that they’re at just about the right levels. Strength in the government’s factory data have been uneven, unlike the strength of ISM’s sample which is steady and impressive.

Markit Manufacturing PMI Hits Eight-Month Low

Image placeholder title

Key Findings

  • Moderate improvement in overall business conditions
  • New orders rise at slowest pace since September 2016
  • Input cost inflation eases to six-month low


Manufacturing Purchasing Managers’ Index™ (PMI™) was above the 50.0 no-change value, but signalled the weakest improvement in business conditions since last September. The latest reading pointed to a further growth slowdown from the 22- month high recorded in January (55.0). Weaker new business growth and softer job creation helped to offset a marginally stronger upturn in production volumes.
May data indicated that manufacturing output increased for the twelfth month running. The rate of expansion picked up slightly from April’s seven-month low, but remained relatively modest overall. Survey respondents noted that subdued new business growth and more cautious inventory policies had acted as a brake on production requirements. Reflecting this, stocks of finished goods were accumulated at a slower pace than seen at the start of 2017. Meanwhile, preproduction inventories dropped for the second month running, which contrasted with robust rates of stock building earlier this year.
New order levels increased again in May, although the rate of expansion was the least marked recorded since September 2016. This was mainly linked to subdued client demand. Some manufacturers also cited weak export sales, as highlighted by a slower upturn in new work from abroad than that seen in April.

Diverging Tones

That’s quite a difference in tone between the reports.

The GDP models focus on ISM, ignoring Markit, but Markit’s assessment has been generally more accurate for a long time.

The ISM assessment of first-quarter GDP was a preposterous 4.3% vs Markit at 1.7. I estimated 0.4% but revised the second estimate to 1.1% following construction revisions.

For details, please see …

  1. Six GDP Estimates (Three Revised Today): ZeroHedge, Mish, GDPNow, Nowcast, ISM, Markit.
  2. First Quarter GDP Second Estimate 1.2 Percent: Mish vs. Consensus

Here is my second estimate Tweet in advance of the report. Amusingly, I was higher than any Econoday economist’s estimate.

I do not have any faith in this ISM report.

Mike “Mish” Shedlock

Services PMI and Non-Manufacturing ISM Diverge Strongly Again

The soft data divergence between the ISM Non-Manufacturing Report on Business and the Markit Services PMI widened again today. Let’s take a look at each report.

ISM vs Markit PMI Divergence Widens Again: Believe Markit

The manufacturing soft-data reports have been nearly unanimous in reporting widespread strength that has not shown up in any hard data reports.

ISM and Markit Manufacturing Reports Skewed by Energy Sector and Airplane Orders?

The divergence between Markit’s US Manufacturing PMI and the ISM’s “Report on Business” narrowed a bit today with both numbers retreating a bit but ISM cooling more.

Another ISM/PMI Divergence: Non-Manufacturing

On April 3, I noted a huge discrepancy between the ISM manufacturing report and Markit’s PMI manufacturing report.

ISM-PMI Divergence Widens: Markit Estimates 2nd Quarter GDP at 1.1%, Says Profit Squeeze Underway

Unlike their counterparts at the ISM, Markit sees growth in both services and manufacturing weakening with U.S. private sector growth at a seven-month low in April.

Markit PMI vs. ISM Fantasyland GDP Projection: Stagflation Lite?

The discrepancy between the ISM’s Report on Business and Markit’s Manufacturing PMI assessment of the economy widened today.

2nd Quarter GDP Estimates from ISM and Markit

On July 3, we discussed the divergence between the Markit and ISM diffusion indexes for manufacturing. Today, let’s look at ISM Nonmanufacturing vs Markit Services.

Slower Expansion in Non-Manufacturing ISM and Markit Services PMI

Business activity growth softened to a 7-month low in Dec. according to Markit. ISM expansion was less than expected.

Tale of Two Indexes: Non-Manufacturing ISM vs Markit PMI

The ISM Non-Manufacturing Index strengthened in October. Markit's Service PMI weakened.