by Mish

The heads of GE, Boeing, and other large corporations have warned that the US may not have another opportunity to revamp its tax code for 30 years if it misses out on a chance to do so now amid uproar over a proposed import tax.
In a letter to Congress, 16 chief executives from exporters including Caterpillar, Dow Chemical, and Pfizer issued their strongest statements of support yet for the import tax, which retailers, oil refiners, and other importers are fighting to kill.
“If we miss this chance to fundamentally reshape the tax code, it might take another 30 years before we have another chance to try,” the chief executives write in a letter to be sent on Tuesday.
The lobbying war between importers and exporters — whose products would go untaxed if shipped overseas under the plan — has already slowed the writing of legislation and prompted some senators to come out against the House plan.

Tax Debate Heats Up

The Wall Street Journal reports As Tax Debate Heats Up, Lawmakers Struggle to Think of a Plan B.

An uncomfortable question looms over the tax debate in Congress: What’s Plan B?
Border adjustment, a pillar of House Republicans’ tax proposal, is taking a beating. Big retailers are lobbying aggressively against the concept, which would tax imports and exempt exports. Senate Republicans have expressed views ranging from skepticism to hostility. Even some House Ways and Means Republicans are wary.
With Democrats sidelined, just three GOP senators could kill the House tax plan; already, more than that oppose border adjustment.
Border adjustment is essential to overhauling the tax code and encouraging investment in the U.S., and House Republicans are going to keep pushing, Rep. Kevin Brady (R., Texas), the plan’s chief architect, said Thursday.
In Mr. Brady’s plan, border adjustment serves two purposes that can’t be easily replicated, experts say. First, it would raise an estimated $1 trillion over a decade to help pay for cutting the corporate tax rate to 20% from 35%. Second, border adjustment reshapes the U.S. tax base around domestic consumption, making it harder for companies to escape U.S. taxes by putting their manufacturing, intellectual property or headquarters outside the country.
Any plausible Plan B—whether from Mr. Brady or importers lining up against him—must grapple with those two challenges.
Deep tax cuts face tougher Senate procedural hurdles that would likely require them to expire after 10 years.
Sen. David Perdue (R., Ga.), a former retail executive, said lawmakers should scrap border adjustment, focusing on lower tax rates and banking on economic growth to make up revenue shortfalls.
“Trust the free enterprise system. Get this tax structure simplified, competitive with the rest of the world and then watch this economy grow,” he said. “I think they’re underestimating the power that this is going to have.”

Six Reasons to Side With Perdue

  1. The border adjustment tax (BAT) proposal is against WTO rules
  2. It will not raise the amount of money expected (tax hikes never do)
  3. It will cripple trade with Mexico
  4. It will decrease competition
  5. It will raise prices for consumers
  6. It will kill jobs

Contrary to popular myth, taxing importers will not bring jobs back to the US. But import taxes would raise prices, decrease competition, and cripple trade, whether or not other countries retaliate.

Since when do raising prices,  decreasing competition, and restricting trade increase jobs?

Trust the Free Enterprise System

Perdue is correct. It’s time to slash the corporate tax rate and trust the free enterprise system. We also need to cut spending and stop warmongering.

Mike “Mish” Shedlock

Import Prices Surge vs Export Prices: Bad News for GDP Forecasts

Both import and export prices rose in April but the primary surge is in import prices.

Law of Bad Ideas

A proposal by French president Francois Hollande got me thinking about “The Law of Bad Ideas“.

Six Reasons Construction Boom Won’t Last

The Census Bureau reports November Construction Spending rose 0.9% from October. That’s a 10-year high, but it’s highly unlikely to last.

Batty Ideas: Boiling Frogs and BATs

The widely believed boiling frog theory says if put a frog in boiling water it will jump out but if you slowly raise the temperature it will stay in until it dies.

Spexit Before Grexit? Six Reasons Spain Will Leave the Euro First

Interest rates on the 10-Year Spanish bond touched 6.7% today after the ECB shot down prime Minister Mariano Rajoy’s Ponzi plan to recapitalize banks.

India Bans Gold Exports “Without a Valid Reason”

In addition to its crackdown on cash, India stepped up its attack on gold. The aim is to cut down on gold imports. India does that in a roundabout way, by cracking down on exports.

Law of Bad Ideas Strikes Again: Reverse Wage and Price Controls

It was bound to happen. Even more radical ideas to produce inflation in a deflationary world have surfaced.

Tax Overhaul: Where Art Thou? Republican Divisions Widening, Mish Suggestion

Trump has promised a sweeping overhaul of the US tax code to protect US exporters.

Rate Hike Cycles vs. the US Dollar: Rate Hikes Bad for Gold?

Here are two different looks at Fed rate hikes since Volcker. The charts are the same, but one presentation is a lot funnier than the other.