by Mish

Under 2003 rules, repayment of Euro bond obligations in Lira may not constitute a credit event. Under newer rules, repayment in Lira would definitely constitute a credit event.

The difference between the two sets of CDS is one measure of redenomination risk.

Eurointelligence offers an interesting discussion of the setup.

Mediobanca’s Antonio Guglielmi has been focusing like no-one else on Italian redenomination risk, which on its own is an indicator that there are serious problems ahead for Italy and the eurozone. In his latest article, he makes an interesting analysis of how to measure this risk, and finds that the difference between the 2003 definition of a credit event for credit default swap and the 2014 definition as a good starting point.

The 2014 definition explicitly adds redenomination as a new criterion for a credit event. And it changed the list of re-denominable currencies from the currencies of the G7 countries to those of Canada, Japan, Switzerland, UK, US and the euro. This means that only redenomination into these currencies would not trigger a credit event. In other words, if Italy redenominates, it is a credit event under the 2014 definition but not (necessarily) under the 2003 definition. Now, both types of CDS are trading, so that the spread between the two serves as a good market measure of redenomination risks. He notes that, in the case of Italy, the rate for the 2014 CDS is 194bp while the rate for the 2003 type CDS is only 126 basis points. The gap of 68bp is thus a metric of the redenomination risk. This is not huge, but it is significantly higher than for France or Spain, and it has gone up in recent months.

We would like to add that as long as these risks are out there – in the sense that serious people are having serious discussions about them – there is no chance of normalization.

2014 CDS Mispriced Relative to 2003

The odds of redenomination in Italy are far greater than CDS would indicate. The only problem is timing it.

A possible play that I think would be an eventual winner would be a bet on redenomination under2014 rules and a bet against under 2003 rules. Such a play does require clarification that redenomination does not constitute a credit even under 2003 rules.

This is a sophisticated play for hedge funds to consider, nothing the average investor should attempt.

Nonetheless, I am quite certain the markets have underpriced redenomination risk, especially in relative terms.

Mike “Mish” Shedlock

Italy’s Zombie Banks on Death Bed, Bail-Ins Coming?

Italy’s third largest bank by assets, Banca Monte dei Paschi is on the death bead. It’s been there since mid-2014.

Run on Italy’s Third Largest Bank? Capital Controls or Bail-Ins Next? Why Take Chances?

Italian Bank Customers Pull Deposits. The CEO of Monte dei Paschi, Italy’s third largest bank, and the oldest surviving bank in the world, admits Customers Pulling Deposits as share prices sink.

Event Risk and Trump’s Weak Dollar Policy

Saxo Bank CIO and chief economist Steen Jakobsen sees event risks on the near horizon in terms of Trump policies and the US dollar.

Italy Aims €20 Billion “Bazooka” at €360 Billion Problem: Bail-ins Coming, Expect More

Bondholder bail-ins are on the way in Italy as private investors pulled the plug on a bank rescue.

Eurozone Growth Slows to 4-Year Low, Italy Stagnates, Global Recession Risk Up

Eurozone growth slows to 0.2%, a four-year low as Italy stagnates. CEBR says risks of a global recession have risen.

End of Euro in Italy: Renzi Faces Three Opposition Parties, All Rabidly Anti-Euro

The nannycrats in Brussels better be working on plan B. Plan A, never let a country leave the Eurozone, is set to fail, sooner or later, and in a country big enough to have massive repercussions.

Refugees Flooding Italy Surge 80%; Italy Seeks Greek-Style Returns.

Italy’s Interior minister Angelino Alfano warns the refugee “system is at risk of collapse” following an 80 per cent spike in the number of arrivals to Italy across the central Mediterranean Sea in the first quarter of this year compared to 2015.

Italy Openly Fighting With EU and Germany.

Athens and Rome Expose Europe’s Greatest Faultlines Italy has €200 billion in non-performing loans, plus another €150bn of troubled debt. It has no productivity growth for 15 years, through its own fault.

Eurozone Day of Reckoning Coming Soon: Showdown Between Italy and Germany

The eurozone cannot survive without Italy. The serious problem at the moment is the Eurozone also cannot survive with Italy.