by Mish

What might a map of the United States look like if we started fresh today?

Please consider What the U.S. Map Should Really Look Like.

State boundaries matter for all sorts of reasons. The state you live in determined how much your vote counted in the 2016 election. It shapes what kind of benefits your employer might offer you, what taxes you pay, what kind of schools you can attend, and much more.
And yet, most state boundaries were drawn during the 17th to 19th centuries, says Garrett Nelson, a historical geographer at Dartmouth College. “Why should we think that areas which were drawn up for horses and buggies still make sense for interstates and telecommuting?”
Nelson, along with Alasdair Rae of the University of Sheffield, has published new research in the journal PLOS ONE that shows how we might redraw state lines today, if given the opportunity. Their insights have profound implications for how business and political leaders can better organize as a region to work toward policies and projects that help their communities, as well as how Americans should think about the rural-urban divide following the 2016 election.
In the study, the researchers used algorithms to analyze data on the commuting paths of more than 4 million Americans from the U.S. Census. They then created maps of what they call economic “mega-regions” — cities, satellite cities, towns and suburbs that are woven together into the communities where Americans live, work and spend their free time. The researchers argue that these, rather than the current states, are the real units that make up the U.S. economy.
In the map below, each “mega-region” is labeled with a different color. All have one or more cities at their centers — the blue area is centered around Chicago, for example, while the forest green stretch encompasses Baltimore and Washington, D.C.

To map out these mega-regions, the researchers used the volume of commuter flow between locations as a proxy for the economic connection between two areas.

The researchers then used an algorithm to identify the best boundaries to 50 economic communities. That’s how they created the map below, showing what our 50 states might look like if they were redrawn today based on economic connections:

RECOMMENDED ARTICLES

Image placeholder title

The researchers say the maps offer a different perspective on the U.S. than the one many people have adopted since the election. The election gave a picture of a country that is starkly divided into urban and rural areas. Yet these maps show that most parts of the country are actually economically well-integrated, Nelson says.
“The reality is that cities, suburbs, exurbs, and rural areas are all extensively connected to one another — not only by commuter traffic, but by all sorts of economic and social connections. While a voter in downtown Boston and a voter in rural Maine might not feel like they have very much in common, our research suggests that they are actually part of an interlocking regional system,” he says.

These maps are not only interesting, but the new divisions seem realistic. Would that have affected the election?

One thing is for sure: Such a map would have changed Trump’s campaign strategy.

For further discussion, please see Campaigning Smart: Would Hillary Really Have Won If Election Was Based on Popular Vote?

Mike “Mish” Shedlock

Fed Hikes Today, Then What?

CME Fedwatch says the Fed Fund Futures show a 95% chance of a hike today. I suggest it’s over 99%. Then what?

Cracks Appear in Philadelphia Fed Regional Manufacturing Report

Actual industrial output has been far weaker than the regional Fed manufacturing reports and the ISM report for at least a year.

Empire State Manufacturing: Another Strong Regional Report Bearing Little Resemblance to Reality

I have not commented on the regional manufacturing reports much lately because they bear no resemblance to reality.

Does Technology Destroy Jobs? If Not What Does?

In light of my posts on robots, driverless vehicles, and automation, readers keep asking: where will the jobs come from?

Eight States Including Illinois Have Not Recovered Jobs Lost in Prior Recessions

Illinois, Alabama, Connecticut, Michigan, Mississippi, New Mexico, Ohio, and Wyoming are the only states that still have not regained employment lost during the Great Recession or prior recessions.

What If You Could Vote for “Nobody”? Who Would Have Won the US Election? What About France?

Polls show close to 40% of French voters are still undecided. That’s a record total this late in the game.

Impeachment Odds Approximately Zero: What’s the Real Reason for Today’s Decline?

The DOW fell over 372 points, the VIX volatility index jumped 46%, gold was up $23, the dollar fell, and treasury yields sank across the board.

Afghanistan: What the Hell Are We Doing?

The US invaded Afghanistan in October of 2001. US troops have been in the country ever since. That’s 16 years. Have we made any progress?

Too Hot to Handle Twist: Econoday “Thankful” for Empire State Manufacturing Cooling

The Econoday consensus estimate for the Empire State manufacturing index was +15.0 in a range of 13.0 to 17.2.