by Mish

That’s two to four strikes against them, depending on how one counts duplicate ideas.

The question at hand is: Have negative interest rates backfired already?

The Wall Street Journal discusses the “early evidence” in Are Negative Rates Backfiring?

Two years ago, the European Central Bank cut interest rates below zero to encourage people such as Heike Hofmann, who sells fruits and vegetables in this small city, to spend more.

Policy makers in Europe and Japan have turned to negative rates for the same reason—to stimulate their lackluster economies. Yet the results have left some economists scratching their heads. Instead of opening their wallets, many consumers and businesses are squirreling away more money.

When Ms. Hofmann heard the ECB was knocking rates below zero in June 2014, she considered it “madness” and promptly cut her spending, set aside more money and bought gold. “I now need to save more than before to have enough to retire,” says Ms. Hofmann, 54 years old.

Recent economic data show consumers are saving more in Germany and Japan, and in Denmark, Switzerland and Sweden, three non-eurozone countries with negative rates, savings are at their highest since 1995, the year the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development started collecting data on those countries. Companies in Europe, the Middle East, Africa and Japan also are holding on to more cash.

There is a growing suspicion that part of problem may be negative rates themselves.

“People only borrow and spend more when they are confident about the future,” says Andrew Sheets, chief cross-asset strategist at Morgan Stanley. “But by going negative, into uncharted territory, the policy actually undermines confidence.”

RECOMMENDED ARTICLES

Low interest rates should encourage consumers and businesses to spend by depressing returns on savings and safe assets such as government bonds. Such spending should create demand for goods, help lift sagging inflation and boost economic growth.

Unintended Consequences

The last paragraph above is rather amusing. Consumers have proven economists wrong (once again).

Data Reflects Anecdotes

Here are a few more anecdotes from the article. Anecdotes do not constitute data, but the data reflects the anecdotes.

Lasse Bohman, a 63-year old newsstand worker from Stockholm, said the concept of negative interest rates is “weird” and makes him want to save more for retirement rather than spend. “I am just going to keep on putting money in the bank,” he says, or “put it under the mattress at home.”

In Germany, Europe’s largest economy and a nation known for thrift, savings as a percentage of disposable household income rose to 9.7% in 2015, according to preliminary data from the OECD. That is the highest rate since 2010, and the OECD expects the savings rate to rise further this year, to 10.4%.

In December, Ms. Hofmann, the Korschenbroich fruit vendor, used her Christmas bonus to buy two 10-gram bars of gold. She has since bought more and has put it, and every euro she can set aside, into a safe at home, saying she doesn’t trust banks. “Every time I check my savings account, it makes me want to cry,” she says.

Money in the Safe

In Japan, the threat of negative interest rates on savings accounts did not spur spending except on safes to hoard cash.

I discussed this back in February in Safes Sold Out in Japan: Customers Hoard Cash in Response to Negative Rates.

Mike “Mish” Shedlock

Confusion Over Negative Interest Rates; What About Safekeeping Fees?

Several readers disagreed with my statement that “negative interest rates cannot occur naturally“.

Negative Interest Rate Mutiny in Germany, Japan

Banks in Japan and Europe are fed up with central bank negative interest rate policies that cost the banks money.

Negative Interest Rates: Can They Ever Occur Naturally? What is the “Natural Rate”?

A question on negative interest rates has arisen in response to Negative Interest Rates: Have They Backfired Already?

Decade of Negative Real Interest Rates: Who Benefited?

Rudy Havenstein Tweeted an interesting chart earlier today on real negative interest rates.

Like Lemmings Over a Cliff: Fed to Test Negative Interest Rates

Low and negative rates have not done a damn thing for the Eurozone, Switzerland, Japan, or any other country that’s implemented them. Nonetheless, Fed lemmings want to Test How Banks Would Handle Negative Rates.

Swiss Bank Hits Customers With Negative Interest Rates; Crazy? What About Velocity?

Alternative Bank Schweiz (ABS), a small bank in Switzerland broke the negative interest rate on deposits barrier, CHARGING customers to take their money. (emphasis in caps from the article).

Is There a Limit to Draghi’s Negative Interest Rate Madness?

On Thursday, ECB president Mario Draghi lowered the deposit rate on money parked at the ECB to -0.4% from -0.3%. Draghi also cut the main refinancing rate by 5 basis points to 0%.

Lagarde Praises Negative Rates, Study Shows They Reduce Lending

Incoming IMF chief Christine Lagarde says negative rates have helped Europe more than they’ve hurt. I disagree.

Negative Interest Rates Are Social Political Poison

The interest rate business model is dead. Negative interest rates killed it, with no replacement in sight.