The New York Fed report on Home Prices, Housing Wealth and Home Equity Extraction provides an interesting look at home prices and home ownership rates before and after the recovery.

Mortgage Debt

Image placeholder title

Home Prices

Image placeholder title

Ownership Rate

Image placeholder title

Home Ownership Rates by Age

Image placeholder title

Housing Wealth

Image placeholder title

Median Borrower Equity 2006

Image placeholder title

Median Borrower Equity 2011

Image placeholder title


Bedian Borrower Equity 2017

Image placeholder title

Wealth Shift

Image placeholder title

Cash Out Refis Pick Up

Image placeholder title

Borrowers Older

Image placeholder title

Leveraging Wealth or Struggling to Pay Bills?

  • 2006 originators were primarily levering up, with a small decline in average credit card balances, and piggybacks a large share
  • 2017 originators’ credit reports show evidence of credit card and student loan consolidation

NY Fed Wrap-UP

  • Home prices have recovered, but homeownership has not, especially for younger Americans, compounded by tight underwriting
  • Housing wealth has shifted toward older, more creditworthy borrowers
  • Equity extraction is relatively low now, considering potential uses to borrowers and high levels of tappable equity

Mish Wrap-Up

  • Congratulations, Fed, you blew another bubble in which new borrowers cannot afford homes.
  • Cash-out refis have accelerated recently.
  • The NAR constantly moans about lack of supply of homes. As boomers die off, supply will increase.

Related Articles

  1. Housing ATM is Back (But it won't work any better this time)
  2. Mortgage Rates Highest Since 2013 Taper Tantrum: "It's Not a Drill, It's Panic"
  3. Fed Tightening Cycles Coincide With Bursting of Asset Bubbles: How to Play It

Mike "Mish" Shedlock

NY Fed Study Shows Household Spending Projections Continue to Slide

Every month, the New York Fed conducts a household survey of consumer expectations. Let's investigate the data.

Study Shows Student Debt Delays Home Buying by Seven Years

The Student Loan Debt and Housing Report 2017 by the National Association of Realtors and the nonprofit group American Student Assistance shows the obvious: Student debt delays household formation, home buying, and saving.

Home Ownership Rates Vary Wildly: What’s Going On?

Reader Duncan Burns, a writer for the “Valley Patriot”, a local newspaper in North Andover, Massachusetts pinged me with an interesting chart on the home ownership rate in Massachusetts.

Huge Interest Rate Dislocations: Did the Fed Cut Too Much?

A series of charts shows new fed-sponsored interest rate dislocations. Let's dive into the charts.

Where is Blockchain Really Used? Nowhere! Study Shows 0% Success Rate

Other than cryptocurrencies, where is blockchain used? A study cannot find anyplace, only tests, proof of concept, etc.

Lagarde Praises Negative Rates, Study Shows They Reduce Lending

Incoming IMF chief Christine Lagarde says negative rates have helped Europe more than they’ve hurt. I disagree.

NY Fed President Dudley Complains Unemployment is Too Low, Rate Hikes Needed

NY Fed President William Dudley is worried about the low unemployment rate. He thinks the Fed needs to be above neutral.

NY Fed President Wants Consumers to Tap Home Equity: Didn’t We Try That Before?

Here’s one that came my way earlier today although the report was from January: New York Fed Chief Dudley has an Idea — Homeowners Should Tap Into Equity.

Fed's Beige Book Shows Tariff Concerns, Agricultural Weakness, Price Pressures

The Beige Book word of the day is "tariff". It was mentioned 37 times and not in a good sense.