by Mish

The Wall Street Journal reports U.S., Canada and Mexico Wrap Up Nafta First Round.

Opening-round talks to remake the North American Free Trade Agreement revealed early fissures dividing the U.S. from Mexico and Canada, including a Trump administration proposal to require a “substantial” portion of autos and auto parts produced under the pact be made in the U.S.
The renegotiation of the trade deal, which was one of President Donald Trump’s main campaign promises and a key pillar of his “America First” agenda aiming to revive U.S. manufacturing and reduce the country’s trade deficit, is likely to face many hurdles. Auto makers in all three nations generally oppose the stricter rules floated by the U.S. negotiator, and pro-business lawmakers in Congress don’t want to see the pact significantly altered.
Early tensions over areas such as the so-called rules of origin—a major issue for the automotive industry—signaled the tough bargaining that lies ahead as the three nations try to wrap up a deal by early next year.
The chief U.S. negotiator, Robert Lighthizer, came into the talks Wednesday saying the U.S. would insist on tightening the rules of origin, and adding a provision covering U.S. production, an idea quickly dismissed as unworkable by Mexican and Canadian officials.
At this early stage of the talks, it is difficult to measure the depth of the disagreement. Opening rounds generally set the tone and schedule for negotiations. The U.S. has yet to release specifics on some of its most controversial positions, including measures to reduce the U.S. trade deficit, prevent currency manipulation, favor U.S. companies in government contracts, known colloquially as Buy America, and rework rules governing arbitration panels.
The U.S. feels that its most significant leverage in the talks is Mr. Trump’s threat to withdraw from Nafta if the U.S. doesn’t get the changes it wants. North American trade is far more significant to the Canadian and Mexican economies than it is for the U.S.
Mexican negotiators say they are prepared to scrap Nafta rather than accede to demands they consider harmful to their economy.

What’s the Best That Can Happen?

That’s a softball question. The best thing that can possibly happen is the trade talks collapse and Trump backs down on his promise to revoke the deal.

Nearly as good would be minor tweaks that don’t really do anything. One might even argue this is a better alternative as it would allow Trump to save face while bragging about nothing.

RECOMMENDED ARTICLES

What’s the Worst That Can Happen?

The worst is the trade talks collapse, Trump abandons NAFTA and starts a global trade war.

What’s Likely?

I suspect there will be trivial to non-trivial but not devastating changes.

Given Trump’s propensity to back down, reverse course, or change his mind on a second’s notice, literally anything is possible.

An ideal trade agreement can fit on a napkin: Effective immediately, all tariffs and all subsidies, on all goods and services ends today.

Mike “Mish” Shedlock

5th Round of NAFTA Talks Collapse: Who's to Blame? What's at Stake?

The 5th round of NAFTA talks between the US, Canada, and Mexico was a complete disaster. It's a lose, lose, lose setup.

Killing the Trade Golden Goose: Farmers Rattled by Trump’s NAFTA Rescinding Plans

It’s fair to presume NAFTA is not the sole cause of the increase in trade, but it is also fair to presume that NAFTA helped.

Trumpian Hardball: Nowhere Close to NAFTA Deal but Progress in China

NAFTA negotiations are in jeopardy, but things are progressing better in China. The difference? China strikes back.

Trump Considers Executive Order Withdrawing From NAFTA: Majorly Stupid

“It’s been very, very bad for our companies and for our workers, and we’re going to make some very big changes or we are going to get rid of NAFTA once and for all,” President Donald Trump said in a speech last week.

Lose Lose Lose Affair: Farm Lobby Turns Up Heat on Trump Over NAFTA

If Trump decides to stick it to Mexico in the upcoming NAFTA talks, US farming industry will take a hit. In advance of the talks, the Farm Lobby is Pressuring Trump.

Trump Cries Wolf – Backs Down On NAFTA Cancellation Already: “Trump’s Bluff Didn’t Come Off”

In a few short hours, Trump went from threatening to pull the plug on NAFTA (again), to stating, “It is my privilege to bring NAFTA up to date through renegotiation.”

Trump Wins Round One In Battle Over His Tax Returns

In a round one victory for Trump, the US Supreme Court suspended a House subpoena regarding Trump’s finances.

NAFTA is Dead: Trump Seeks Separate Agreements With Mexico and Canada

Trump proposes NAFTA by another name. But it won't look like NAFTA. He wants tailored bilateral trade agreements.

Disputing Trump’s NAFTA “Catastrophe” with Pictures: What’s the True Source of Trade Imbalances?

President Trump and his trade czar, Peter Navarro, are moaning and groaning about NAFTA and the US trade imbalance with Mexico.