by Mish

Although unasked, the same question seems to apply to me.

Reader Drew writes …

Hi Mish
I know you are a fan of Sal Khan and Khan Academy. I’m wondering if you were aware of his background, his brilliance, and his decision to give away his courses for free.
My question is do you consider what he is doing socialism? How does one explain his decision not to use his brilliance for personal gain and instead to donate his time and energy on something he gives away for free? Isn’t that a contradiction of capitalism?
Many thanks.

Definition of Socialism

What’s contradictory about it?

To address that question, please consider a Definition of Socialism.

Socialism: a way of organizing a society in which major industries are owned and controlled by the government rather than by individual people and companies.
In the modern era, “pure” socialism has been seen only rarely and usually briefly in a few Communist regimes. Far more common are systems of social democracy, now often referred to as “democratic socialism,” in which extensive state regulation, with limited state ownership, has been employed by democratically elected governments (as in Sweden and Denmark) in the belief that it produces a fair distribution of income without impairing economic growth.

In general, socialists believe in higher taxes and equatable distribution of wealth via government ownership, wealth redistribution schemes, and higher taxes on the wealthy.

Giving away things for free does not make one a socialist.

My blog is free. ZeroHedge’s blog is free. So is the Acting Man blog. None of us are remotely socialistic.

Yes, we make money off our blogs from advertising.


Ironically, making money off blogging was never my intent. I launched my blog in hopes of being discovered a writer. It never happened. No one wanted me.

The Motley Fool turned me down for an opening they had for a writer even though I had a very popular forum on that site at the time.

For me, making money at blogging required 18 hour days, nearly 365 days a year, for three years before I made more than a few hundred dollars a month off Google ads.

ZeroHedge is a master. He took things to the next level, very quickly.

Let’s go another level higher. Quarter after quarter Amazon.Com loses money or makes little. Is Amazon a socialistic company?

Losing money or giving things away for free while making money is not socialistic in and of itself.

None of us promote government ownership of things or massive wealth redistribution schemes. At least I don’t.

Neither I nor Khan make demands of others. We do not propose robbing from the rich to give to the poor. We do not whine for higher taxes. We do not whine for government takeovers.

Don’t confuse either “free” or “nonprofit” with socialism. Neither term is in the definition.

Government and Fed interference has driven up prices. Everything government touches drives up costs.

Free market capitalism reduces costs. Free is the ultimate in capitalism but the Fed and public unions fight free vehemently.

Mike “Mish’ Shedlock

Reader Asks: Can the Bubbles Last Forever?

Reader Bob wants to know if the Fed can keep various bubbles levitated forever. Here is his specific question followed by my response.

Reader Asks “What Will Happen When Robots Take Our Jobs”

Reader Peter is concerned about the future of jobs, living wages, and displaced workers in a robotic society.

Reflections and Reader Comments on Free Trade: “China Doesn’t Play Fair!”

Reader Cathy, a member of the US Military Intelligence Brigade pinged me about free trade.

Discussion of Target2 and the ELA (Emergency Liquidity Assistance) program; Reader From Europe Asks

“Can You Please Explain Target2?”. Reader Thomas who lives in the Netherlands writes …

Squawking Parrots vs. Mish on Free Trade

Microsoft founder Bill Gates is a “Unabashed Pro-Free Trade Person“.

Readers Question Free Trade; Does Nonreciprocal Free Trade Cost Jobs? Paul Krugman “Was” Right!

I received many questions and comments regarding Obama’s Trans-Pacific Partnership Fiasco vs. Mish’s Proposed Free Trade Alternative.

Reader Asks About Shorting Subprime Auto Sector

A question and some interesting observations came in today from reader “FW” who works at Ford. He asks about shorting the auto sector including auto-backed collateralized loans.

Reader Asks About “Fedcoin”: Should the Fed Issue Its Own Bitcoin?

Are central banks planning to issue their own digital currencies? If so, is there anything to fear? Those are the questions at hand today as reader Ken asked “Could you post your opinion of Fedcoin?”

Debunking MMT, Keynesianism, Monetarism: Reader asks “What theories do you believe?”

In Central Banks Puzzled as Global Inflation Hits Lowest Level Since 2009: Solving the Puzzle