The BEA reports the Gross Domestic Product, 3rd quarter 2018 (advance estimate) is 3.5%.

The headline number looks pretty good, but it isn't. Change in Private Inventories accounted for 2.07 percentage points of the gain.

Inventories net to zero over time. That inventory accumulation makes sense only if sales match. Rather, I suspect we had an accumulation of goods related to Trump tariffs, and secondarily we have business optimism that is unwarranted.

Contributions to Change in GDP

Image placeholder title

In addition to the huge 2.07 CIPI (line 40), note that government consumption (line 50) added 0.56 percentage points.

A little bit of election spending perhaps? Of Course. Compare to 2017.


Also note residential fixed investment (line 39). Are we really to believe that with the housing slowdown for six month that the result is only -0.16 percentage points.

Net exports (line 43) took away a whopping 1.78 percentage points, with imports rising and exports shrinking. This we call "winning the trade war".

Note that imports don't really subtract. Rather they reflect spending that never happened in some of the other numbers.

CIPI alone is enough to make this report look better than it really was. And no to that you can add residential housing and government spending.

Check out the plane orders in Durable Goods Mirage: Good Headline Number, Very Poor Details. New orders +0.8%, Excluding Defense -0.6%.

Related Articles

  1. Explaining Imports: Think Imports and Trade Deficits Impact GDP? Think Again!
  2. GDPNow vs Nowcast: Final GDP Estimates for GDPNow and Nowcast Tick Lower
  3. Tariff Scorecard: 57 Companies Bitch About Trump's Tariffs, 7 Give Positive View
  4. New Housing: Thud! Sept New Home Sales Plunge 5.5% from Dramatically Revised Lower August
  5. Housing Resales: Existing Home Sales are Down for the 6th Consecutive Month

Mike "Mish" Shedlock

Weaker Than Expected GDP: Mixed Bag or Worse?

Fourth Quarter real GDP came in at 2.6%. Nowcast estimated 3.9%, GDPNow 3.4%. Let's dive into the report.

Email Exchange With GDPNow Creator Pat Higgins on GDP Inventory Adjustments

GDPNow forecasts an inventory adjustment of -1.09 percentage points this quarter. What's going on?

Third-Quarter GDP Hits Consensus 3.3% Estimate

The BEA reported the second estimate of third-quarter GDP was 3.3%. The report matched the Econoday consensus.

Ignore the Headline, Real GDP is Much Worse Than It Looks

The initial estimate of 4th-Quarter GDP was 2.1%, about where analysts expected. but the details are another matter.

Inventory Report a Bit Weaker than Expected

Economists expected a bit stronger inventory report heading into tomorrow's GDP report.

Third-Quarter GDP Revised Slightly Lower in 3rd Estimate: What's Next?

In its third and final estimate of the third-quarter GDP, the economy grew at 3.2%. The revision is statistical noise.

Final Model Forecasts for First Quarter GDP: GDPNow 2.0%, Nowcast 2.9%

The advance (first) estimate of first-quarter GDP is published tomorrow. The GDPNow final estimate is 2.0%, Nowcast 2.9%

GDP a strong 4.1%, Saving Rate Revised Much Higher, Talk of Overheating

The BEA released the 2nd Quarter 2018 GDP (Advance Estimate) including a Comprehensive Update: 1929 Through 2018 Q1.

Third Estimate of 4th Quarter GDP is 2.1%

Given that GDP is one of the most revised measures, the BEA renamed “final” to “third”. The third estimate is 2.1% just a tick over the Econoday consensus estimate of 2.0%.