Deficits Should Rise During Recessions, Not Booms

The Committee for a Responsible Federal Budget notes the Deficit Has Never Been This High When the Economy Was This Strong.

Rarely have deficits risen when the economy is booming. And never in modern U.S. history have deficits been so high outside of a war or recession (or their aftermath).

The federal budget deficit has only exceeded 4.6 percent eight times since 1950. Four of those years were during and immediately following the Great Recession of 2009, and the other four followed the 1981-82 recession (which was followed by large tax cuts and a defense buildup near the end of the Cold War). Most smaller spikes in the deficit also took place during or immediately after a war or recession.

Output Gap

Image placeholder title

Going Forward

Going forward, deficits are projected to rise even assuming the economy remains stable. Under current law, CBO projects deficits in 2028 will exceed 5 percent of GDP, and under a (perhaps more realistic) Alternative Fiscal Scenario that assumes Congress continues recently enacted policies, deficits will reach 7.1 percent of GDP in ten years.

The same pattern holds with employment rates – the deficit has typically moved in the same direction as the unemployment rate. Yet the current unemployment rate of 3.7 percent is the lowest since 1969, and the deficit is high and rising. All other recent periods of high deficits have been accompanied by high unemployment.

What's the Problem?


Apparently, there is none.

Trump brags about the stock market every chance he gets.

To support Trump's mind-blowing deficits, he needs lower interest rates.

Moreover, the Fed is willing to accommodate Trump.

Bubbles Be Goode

Image placeholder title

In case you missed my musical Fed tribute, please enjoy Bubbles B. Goode: Musical Tribute to the Fed.

Mike "Mish" Shedlock

Understanding Trump's Trade War Tactics in One Picture

For the 42nd time, Trump reports trade war progress with China.

Surefire Recession Signal in Pictures

The strength of inversions widened today. That's a strong recession warning, but it is not the actual recession signal.

Senate Battle in One Picture

The midterm election coming up in November. I expect Democrats will take the House. The Senate is iffy for Democrats.

Why the Yield Curve Inverts in One Simple Picture

The yield curve inverts when the Fed keeps hiking in the face of a slowdown.

Exploring the "Dollar Crash" Thesis in Pictures

People have been predicting a crash in the US dollar for something like forever. Let's investigate another crash thesis.

Flattening Yield Curve in One Picture

The flattening yield curve is a topic of much discussion. The lead chart shows various spreads it in one picture.

Big Investment Boom Following Trump Tax Cuts? Answer in Four Charts

Many expect a big investment boom thanks to Trump tax cuts. A few charts will show why they are mistaken.

One Heck of a Recession Party!

Stocks are on a tear. Celebrating rate cuts. With the rate cuts comes a recession. No recession? No more rate cuts.

Housing Bubble and Everything Bubble in One Simple Picture

To understand the magnitude of the housing bubbles simply compare the index of wages to the index of prices.