Don’t Miss a Post. Subscribe now.

At Least 12 Million Face Eviction as Moratorium Ends

Note: In all charts “Total Renters” means individuals living in households that pay rent, not households. All other chart numbers are individuals.

See Addendums I and II for updates. 

With millions of renters at risk Biden Asks Congress to Extend Federal Eviction Moratorium

State and local governments have struggled to distribute $47 billion in federal money aimed at helping tenants who can’t pay rent because of the pandemic-triggered downturn, leaving many people at risk of being forced out of their homes when the moratorium expires.

Just $3 billion of the aid authorized by Congress in December and March had been delivered to landlords and tenants as of June 30, the Treasury Department said in a report last week. 

Meanwhile, many landlords have been squeezed because they have been unable to collect rent but remain on the hook for taxes, maintenance and other bills.

The moratorium, which originated from an executive order signed by then President Donald Trump last August, shields tenants who have missed monthly rent payments from being forced out of their homes if they declare financial hardship. They still owe the back rent.

The moratorium was originally set to expire Dec. 31, 2020, but Congress extended it until late January, and the CDC has extended the order three times.

in June, the Supreme Court rejected an emergency request to clear the way for evictions after the Biden administration said it would extend the moratorium for one final month. Justice Brett Kavanaugh voted with the 5-4 majority to keep the moratorium in place. However, he issued a one-paragraph concurrence saying he believed the moratorium was unlawful, but was willing to leave it in place for July. “In my view, clear and specific congressional authorization (via new legislation) would be necessary for the CDC to extend the moratorium past July 31,” he wrote.

Census Department Data

I created the lead chart from a Census Department Data Feed. 

Here are a few more charts. 

Confidence in Ability to Pay Mortgage 

Note: In all charts “Total Homeowners” means total number of people living in owner occupied homes. All other chart numbers are individuals.

Mortgage Payment Status

Rent Payment Status

These numbers are way understated. 

Q: How do I know that?
A: Every chart is missing 72,166,927 individuals in which the Census Department does not have tenure data. 

The total is 50,922,215 living in rental households  + 127,127,307 living in owner occupied homes + 72,166,927 unknowns. 

Some of those unknowns are not current or in trouble even if they are current.

Four-Point Synopsis 

  • 7.43 million in rental properties are not current
  • 5.95 million owner occupied housing are not current
  • 8.71 million live in owner occupied homes where the homeowners have little or no confidence in ability to pay their mortgage
  • 12.71 million live in rental properties where the heads of household have little or no confidence in ability to pay their rent

Significant Other Details 

  • The above numbers are undoubtedly understated because the status of 72.17 million households is unknown.
  • Rent plus back rent is due August 1.
  • There will be no more rent moratoriums without Congressional action as per Supreme Court Justice Brett Kavanaugh.
  • On September 1, Federal unemployment benefits expire. 

US 2nd-Quarter GDP Exceeds Pre-Pandemic High But Huge Concerns Remain

Earlier today I reported US 2nd-Quarter GDP Exceeds Pre-Pandemic High But Huge Concerns Remain

This has been a tale of two recoveries. Those with assets and jobs, and those without. 

Many millions of people will not see this as an end to the recession.

Prediction Question

What, Me Worry?

Fed Says Inflation Might be Higher and More Persistent Than They Expect

Making matters worse for everyone struggling, the Fed is hell bent on increasing inflation. 

For details, please see Fed Says Inflation Might be Higher and More Persistent Than They Expect

And finally, the Progressives in congress want an energy tax that will raise the price of literally everything.

For discussion, please see The Stagflation Threat is Very Real but Congress Holds the Key

Wow. What a setup!

Addendum

The Census Bureau says there are 126.338 Million Households

I have a question into the census bureau as to whether the data download and charts reflect individuals or households.

Addendum II

I got a hold of the Census Dept on Friday, but the wrong person. I have another call in.

The person who did call back suggested the numbers likely reflect individuals not households. 

I changed the title of the article and the text above to reflect individuals instead of households. That is my base assumption now.

I believe I have a way of translating individuals to households that I need to confirm. Still, 12 million people at risk of eviction is a lot.

Subscribe!

Like these reports? I hope so, and if you do, please Subscribe to MishTalk Email Alerts.

Subscribers get an email alert of each post as they happen. Read the ones you like and you can unsubscribe at any time.

If you have subscribed and do not get email alerts, please check your spam folder.

Mish

Subscribe to MishTalk Email Alerts.

Subscribers get an email alert of each post as they happen. Read the ones you like and you can unsubscribe at any time.

This post originated on MishTalk.Com

Thanks for Tuning In!

Mish

Comments to this post are now closed.

31 Comments
Newest
Oldest Most Voted
scottel
scottel
5 years ago
Rent free living has been ongoing for 18 months.  Prior to the CDC the President and Governors had killed evictions as rents went past due in March 2020.  Tenants in that time collected two stimulus checks, two EIC checks, multiple $600 sweetened unemployment checks, and now ongoing $300 sweetened unemployment and $250 monthly per child.  Rents were not paid because the tenants did not have to pay them, same as noted here about people not paying their student loans.  When/if the Jubilee comes to an end it will be one heck of a lifestyle reckoning for those not paying their bills.
Since2008
Since2008
5 years ago
Maybe the numbers include college students who are renters but also have bedrooms at their parents ‘ houses.
Hansa Junchun
Hansa Junchun
5 years ago
12,000,000 households being evicted means “Go long on moving vans” because that’s all it is: a shortage of u-hauls to move deadbeats out of one apartment and into another down the street. Landlords need renters and renters CAN pay but don’t want to. So they’ll get evicted and move to another place. There won’t be 12,000,000 homeless families on the streets.
Markab
Markab
5 years ago
We will see about that.
I completely expect that Congress will piece together an 11th hour bailout to keep squatters in (not) their homes. The CDC would have done so already yet again, but their edicts were struck down by at least two Appellate courts with Justice Kavanaugh stating that should the case come before the Court, it is likely to be ruled that the United States of America/CDC “overreached” their authority. No surprise there. Expect more such overreaches and blatant violation of Federal law by our government to come.
KidHorn
KidHorn
5 years ago
So, the new normal will be unemployed people can never be evicted? The state will pay their rent?
I saw something on the news the other day. A lot of states have money that has gone unclaimed. The news said there’s too much paperwork involved. Seems having to prove where you live and prove you’re unemployed by showing your prior year tax return and a drivers license is too onerous. Same logic explains how voter ID is like Jim Crow all over again. Unless you’re living here illegally and/or being paid under the table, this shouldn’t be a problem. So, it’s not enough for democrats to have illegals vote. They also need to get free room.
BobHertz
BobHertz
5 years ago
Reply to  KidHorn
The fact that $44 billion in assistance has gone unclaimed is very troubling indeed. 
I wonder if you have to apply on-line. Uploading forms and dealing with government websites is not easy for me, and I am highly educated and with a good computer.  A person with no education and only a computer at the library will have a lot of problems getting this done,
Some tenants will not even try for aid until they have an eviction notice in their mailbox. Sad but true.
It would be much simpler to just compensate the landlords!
TechLover1
TechLover1
5 years ago
Many states have their own eviction moratoriums.
NJ, for example, has eviction moratorium until Jan 2022. Many other states have it till Aug/Sep/Oct.
I suspect congress will pass something to extend it by two to three months.
Not sure how deflationary it will be as there is about 80 billion in rental aid that will eventually be paid to the landlords.
This will likely just consolidate ownership from small owners to large corporate owners who have access to financing. Mom and Pop landlords will be forced to sell because of cash flow problems. More consolidation of rental ownership ahead.
Greggg
Greggg
5 years ago
Holy crap, a huge rudderless ship.   I can help a little bit with those statistics though.  Every 4 years the Census Bureau drop off a census form at our northern location (2nd home) and shoves in in the storm door (we never had a mail box).  We always fill it out and send it in letting them know it is a vacation home.  Last year we didn’t get one.
Jackula
Jackula
5 years ago
Wow! This will be a deflationary hit!
anoop
anoop
5 years ago
This is very sad and scary.
Webej
Webej
5 years ago
Apocalyptic Numbers
How’s that for inclusivity and keeping everybody aboard!
hhabana
hhabana
5 years ago
I see “Help Wanted” posters everywhere. Stores, vehicles, etc. 
I have no remorse for these people. If they had a death in the family or some illness, then of course, but for the most part you can get a job. People do not want to work. I see this. I work with people who can get overtime to cover extra expenses, but choose to sell their vehicle because it becomes an extra expense. That last one is a true story. I can’t tell you how much “extra” I worked from my later 20’s through my early 50’s. That “extra” was used to pay bills, buy things/vacations or expenses that I had to get rid of. I try to explain this to people (young and my age) and they say forget it. Then live that way. I shed no tears. 
Mish
Mish
5 years ago
Renters: 51 million + 72 million Unknown == roughly 126 million households the BLS says we have
What I do not understand is owner occupied housing. 
If there are 126 million households why is there 127 million owner occupied units + another 72 million unknown.
I suspect they have an error on owner-occupied units.
I was going to post some additional charts but now I am going to contact them instead.
Webej
Webej
5 years ago
Reply to  Mish
Maybe it’s all the home owners paying OER to themselves?? (-:
TexasTim65
TexasTim65
5 years ago
Reply to  Mish
Mish, I scrolled down to the bottom of 1A and 1B (owner and renter). The first column in the spreadsheet marked ‘Total’ has an asterisk on it. When you scroll to the bottom it says (from 1A):
*Total includes only individuals who reported living in owner-occupied housing units and excludes those living in different types of housing units, and also those who did not report their housing situation.
So that says to me that total represents the total number of people who replied and not the total number of households (housing units). In other words, you can get double counts from a husband and wife who both reply. I suspect this is what they are going to tell you.
Eddie_T
Eddie_T
5 years ago
A private survey of small California landlords(who own 10 or less units)……(N=100)……89% reported not losing income. 68% look to own more property within 10 years. Most (79%) say they will not buy in California in the future. Props to Mike Zuber.
Felix_Mish
Felix_Mish
5 years ago
“The moratorium was originally set to expire Dec. 31, 2020, but Congress
extended it until late January, and the CDC has extended the order three
times.
“
Double-take. Eh?
Does the money to pay for all this come out of the CDC’s budget? If not, then why does the CDC have control over any of this? If so, then isn’t it time for some governmental re-organization, what with a disease outfit having a side business in housing.
The vibe here seems as crooked as the liar-loan situation in ’07.
Jojo
Jojo
5 years ago
Reply to  Felix_Mish
I believe the CDC just issues orders w/o having to pay the costs of the order.
Whatever, they can’t do that any longer, so Biden’s only option is to convince Congress to issue an extension.  Will they do it?
Greggg
Greggg
5 years ago
Reply to  Jojo
2 days left and I hope CONgress goes on extended recess.   
Mish
Mish
5 years ago
Doublechecking it clearly says “household”
Moreover it lists the number of people per household.
Here is the link again if anyone wants to have a look.
I will post an addendum with the number of people affected in just a bit
TexasTim65
TexasTim65
5 years ago
Reply to  Mish
I replied below to another post where you asked same thing. After looking at the spread sheet it appears the ‘total’ represents the number of individuals who replied (or didn’t reply).
Six000mileyear
Six000mileyear
5 years ago
Regardless of the moratorium, 15% of the households not being current on payments can’t last forever. There is enough debt coming due that won’t be repaid that a recession is closer than most imagine.
Dr. Manhattan23
Dr. Manhattan23
5 years ago
This is deflationary
Yes, I think some of the current inflation is baked in for good
Eddie_T
Eddie_T
5 years ago
Very few homeowners are upside down this time…due at least partly to the rapid price appreciation in houses. The number of actual foreclosures is going to end up being rather low I think. 24% of those who went into mortgage forbearance never missed a payment. Most of the rest are going to get workout deals. Look at these numbers.
The renters who couldn’t (or didn’t) pay will walk away with their credit wrecked…..but they have nothing to go after….so they won’t pay anything, and almost all of them will figure out a way to keep a roof over their heads, I believe.  The landlords who got stiffed? Some of them will take a big hit. My only lost rent was from the guy who died….his house goes up for rent tomorrow, for substantially more than he was paying.  That was an expensive mess, but I won’t lose the house. I just won’t make any money on it this year.
KyleW
KyleW
5 years ago
With so much unemployment money available most people have no excuse for not paying rent. We shouldn’t have allowed tenants to be freeloaders at all. Property owners still have to pay mortgages, taxes, and homeowners insurance. It’s not fair to them to be paying for someone else’s housing.
Pacioli
Pacioli
5 years ago
If the moratorium does indeed end, that will be a significant disinflationary force.
Mish
Mish
5 years ago
Reply to  Pacioli
agreed
ajc1970
ajc1970
5 years ago
Reply to  Pacioli
Yeah, but I’m trying to picture how it plays out.

Each state will have its own timelines based on existing law.  In some states, landlords will be rushing to be first in line for the courts.  Probably lots of squatters while courts work through eviction order backlogs.

TexasTim65
TexasTim65
5 years ago
Reply to  ajc1970
Ideally for landlords they go with a ‘zoom’ meeting like they have done for most court cases during the pandemic. If they do, they could rubber stamp a lot of evictions daily and work through the backlog in reasonably short order (few months).
If it requires in person hearings in a court it could take years giving squatters another year of free rent (essentially 2+ years).
Mish
Mish
5 years ago
Reply to  TexasTim65
varies widely by state – and judge within state
hhabana
hhabana
5 years ago
Reply to  TexasTim65
I’ve dealt with evictions here in California. They go A LOT quicker than another year. An eviction attorney (he does all day long and this is his specialty) charges about 700 bucks (maybe more now since I haven’t done one in about several years) and does the paperwork, etc. 
Usually, that person is out in 1 1/2-2 months. 2 months if they contest it which is just wasting time as the judge does not care about their circumstances, just if the law has been followed with the eviction process. There is no hands wringing and tears counting for anything and the tenants are not allowed to even talk. It’s done very business like. I’ve sat through these court cases several times.

Decorate Your Walls with Mish Fine Art Images

Click each image to view details or purchase in the store.

Stay Informed

Subscribe to MishTalk

You will receive all messages from this feed and they will be delivered by email.