It’s a “savagely brutal map” for Republicans in 2028. Meanwhile, Trump is Trump.
Brutal National Map
Republicans will be defending 19 seats in 2028. Incoming National Republican Senatorial Committee (NRSC) Chair Sen. Bernie Moreno has described the upcoming cycle as a “savagely brutal map”.
This is how specific political analysts and news organizations break down the most vulnerable GOP-held seats.
Compiled by AI with analyses from outlets like Newsweek and forecasters such as Chris Cillizza.
Primary Republican Targets
Analyses from outlets like Newsweek and forecasters such as Chris Cillizza highlight several top-tier targets.
- Ron Johnson (Wisconsin): Ranked by Cillizza as the #1 most vulnerable Republican seat, driven by his narrow 1-point win in 2022, potential retirement considerations, and a Democratic gubernatorial win in Wisconsin in 2026.
- Ted Budd (North Carolina): Ranked #3 overall by Cillizza, facing pressure after winning his 2022 seat by a slim three-point margin, alongside strong statewide Democratic performances in 2026.
- Chuck Grassley (Iowa): Ranked #6 overall, with vulnerability tied to age and potential retirement questions at age 93, coupled with recent Democratic victories in Iowa’s other Senate and gubernatorial races.
Newsweek
Other vulnerable GOP seats
Several experts expressed that other Republican senators up for election in 2028 could also be vulnerable, such as Lisa Murkowski in Alaska; Jerry Moran in Kansas; and Ashley Moody, who just won a special election in Florida.
In Alaska, a highly competitive Senate race between Democrat Mary Peltola and Republican Senator Dan Sullivan remains undecided. Kansas voters just elected Adam Hamilton to the Senate, the first Democrat to represent the state in the upper chamber since 1932.
While some specific Senate seats come to mind as being vulnerable, University of Florida professor of political science Sharon Austin told Newsweek that she believes all U.S. senators up for election in 2028 are vulnerable.
“This election proved that Democratic candidates can win when Democrats vote,” she said.
Newsweek’s reporters and editors used Martyn, our AI assistant, to produce this story.
Summary of Top At-Risk GOP Seats
| Senator | State | Key Risk Factors Cited in November 2026 Analyses |
|---|---|---|
| Ron Johnson | Wisconsin | Won 2022 by 1 point; potential retirement; state elected a Democratic governor in 2026. |
| Ted Budd | North Carolina | Won 2022 with 50.5%; state’s other Senate seat flipped to a Democrat by a wide margin in 2026. |
| Chuck Grassley | Iowa | Age 93 and potential retirement; Democrats won Iowa’s other Senate seat and governor’s race in 2026. |
| Jerry Moran | Kansas | Has not committed to running in 2028; Democrats won Kansas’s other Senate seat in 2026. |
| Lisa Murkowski | Alaska | Competitive state environment after strong Democratic showings in 2026 races. |
| Tim Scott | South Carolina | State’s other Senate seat flipped to Democrats in 2026; highlighted by GOP leadership as a seat to defend. |
| Ashley Moody | Florida | Flagged by Newsweek and Nate Silver as a potential target in a broader Democratic wave scenario. |
Democrats will be defending 16 seats to Republican’s 19.
Democrats have the enormous advantage of watching Trump make mistake after mistake for two more years.
Off the top of my head, Johnson and Budd are most at risk. If Grassley has any health issues, a Democrat Iowa governor would appoint a Democrat replacement.
Republican-Held Seats (19)
- Alabama: Katie Britt
- Alaska: Lisa Murkowski
- Arkansas: John Boozman
- Florida: Ashley Moody (won the 2026 special election to retain her appointed seat)
- Idaho: Mike Crapo
- Indiana: Todd Young
- Iowa: Chuck Grassley
- Kansas: Jerry Moran
- Kentucky: Rand Paul
- Louisiana: John Kennedy
- Missouri: Eric Schmitt
- North Carolina: Ted Budd
- North Dakota: John Hoeven
- Oklahoma: James Lankford
- South Carolina: Tim Scott
- South Dakota: John Thune
- Tennessee (Special Election): Seat vacated by Marsha Blackburn
- Utah: Mike Lee
- Wisconsin: Ron Johnson
Most of those are safe. I think. But I may not think that way after two more years of Trump.
Senator Mike Lee is not safe already. Had the Utah Dummymander attempt failed, analysis shows Democrats would have won all the Utah House seats.
In Utah, in 2026, there were more Democrat than Republican votes. If Democrats can find a moderate LDS democrat to run in 2028, we are seriously discussing kissing Senator Lee goodbye.
In the above list, Lee would be my top target for his ignorant racism support of the SAVE act and MAGA adherence to whatever Trump wants.
Democratic-Held Seats (16)
- Arizona: Mark Kelly
- California: Alex Padilla
- Colorado: Michael Bennet
- Connecticut: Richard Blumenthal
- Georgia: Raphael Warnock
- Hawaii: Brian Schatz
- Illinois: Tammy Duckworth
- Maryland: Chris Van Hollen
- Nevada: Catherine Cortez Masto
- New Hampshire: Maggie Hassan
- New York: Chuck Schumer
- Ohio: Sherrod Brown (flipped the seat from Republican Jon Husted in the 2026 special election)
- Oregon: Ron Wyden
- Pennsylvania: John Fetterman
- Vermont: Peter Welch
- Washington: Patty Murray
Certainly, not all of those are safe either. For starters, Fetterman is a goner. He will be primaried and lose unless he drops out.
His replacement is likely to be a Democrat.
My Six-Point Base Case
- Trump will continue his economically illiterate tarffs.
- Trump will continue his racist and economically illiterate deportations.
- Stephen Miller will continue to run policy.
- Inflation will not be under control.
- The Fed will hike rates and cause a recession.
- Trump will get the blame.
In short, I expect Trump will be Trump.
Also, we will be dealing with an AI bubble that is now bursting coupled with sustained inflation due to spending out of control (or a nasty recession that kills demand and the stock market).
What Can Go Wrong With My Forecast?
Admittedly, this is early. Two years is along time in politics.
I suppose Trump could broker a deal between Russia and Ukraine. And I suppose there could be a happy outcome in Iran.
However, I see no relief from Trump’s absurd tariffs or economically ignorant and morally wrong deportation policies.
The Real Question
The real question: If Trump gets the blame (or credit) for what happens in the next two years with the stock market, AI, jobs, deportations, inflation, interest rates, and housing, what happens?
My answer is Trump will get the blame for whatever goes wrong, and Trump being Trump, a lot will go wrong on top of things outside his control (including the stock market, recession, housing, and the Fed).
If so, look for a Democrat trifecta in 2028, with Democrats holding 60 or more Senate seats.
And with 60 Senate seats, there will be no need to kill the filibuster.



I think Mish is correct. Demographics is rapidly changing, Millenials and Zoomerz lean left and socialist. Boomers lean right and they are rapidly in decline. If 5000 boomers die each day then how many will be gone between now and 2028?
Couple that with Trump threatening to block anything the blue wave is trying to do along with his geriatric bigot sexist antics and he will definitely cost the GOP votes. Even if its just 10% of the vote, the GOO doesnt have votes to spare. RIP GOP.
I think Ron Johnson (WI) is worried – he has been heard to say that SS should be shut down – but is now recommending a rescue plan!
Yes, Sen. Fetterman will be voted out – he has an unstable public image.
Fetterman has been Mossadomized.
we call him Young Frankenstein
In addition, the replacement of traditional American voters (with some appreciation of a limited republic and the Bill of Rights) with millions of immigrants from countries with cultures accustomed to big, corrupt governments has proceeded at quite a pace. Imported demographics massively favors the Dems.
Yeah, a lot can happen. Best thing dems can do is not get drug into the culture wars pass sound policies for all Americans. I expect the Republican machine to start focusing on witch hunts of their members. But maybe when the convictions start rolling most will see the graft.
I try to balance out my media with a bit of conservative talk radio. The spin is amazing.
it’s a single party government from now on. you better have a solid plan to accept it. the mid term election=is the day the music died😶
Imo the answers are in the middle. I would prefer issue based voting not party line voting.
That’s great news!
So when do the wars stop and Epstein clients publicly executed?
“Blame” – that’s a good one!
If there was any lesson from 2026, candidate quality matters. A LOT. The key question to me is how much will MAGA/Trump influence primaries. If significant, then Republican candidate quality will be low and the Democrats will probably pick up Senate seats.
But there are a lot of factors:
In other words, predicting 2028 is damn near impossible.
Phil
People said that about 2026.
If I am not mistaken I did pretty well 11-months out actually, in January, with this comment: Republicans will lose every close race and then some.
This is a preliminary forecast. But Trump will be Trump and he will make matters worse for himself.
That and a tough setup is all one needs to make a reasonable early forecast, subject to change of course.
Q: Will Dems screw up?
A: Of course.
Q: Will Trump screw up more?
A: Of course
The rogue, deranged idiot will continue to rape and pillage regardless of the makeup of Congress, the US Constitution or the nation’s laws.