Trump’s Trade Deal With China is Way Underperforming Promises

Remember the Phase One trade deal between the US & China? 

Let’s check in with the Peterson Institute for International Economics PIIE US-China Phase One Tracker to see how Trump’s trade deal is going.

Phase One Imports and Exports 

The Tracker shows that as of March 2020, China’s purchases of all covered products were around 40-46% of their year-to-date targets.

Note the huge difference between what China says it is importing vs what the US says it is exporting.

Agriculture

  • China Imports: $5.1 Billion
  • US Exports: $3.1 Billion

Manufactured Goods

  • China Imports: $14.6 Billion
  • US Exports: $10.9 Billion

Energy

  • China Imports: $0.1 Billion
  • US Exports: $0.4 Billion

Uncovered

  • China Imports: $7.7 Billion
  • US Exports: $7.6 Billion

Two Sets of Numbers

  • China says it imported $27.5 Billion.
  • The US says it exported $22.0 Billion

Agreement Methodology

The agreement’s Chapter 6, Article 6.2.6 states “Official Chinese trade data and official US trade data shall be used to determine whether this Chapter has been implemented.” One implication is that there are two sets of monthly data to track (Chinese imports and US exports). A second is that there are two different annual, and hence monthly, targets, since the 2017 baseline level of Chinese imports differs from the 2017 baseline level of US exports. 

The amazing Trump trade team negotiated those fine stipulations.

Bear in mind that the March numbers are before Covid-19 significantly hit the US, but had already hit China hard.

Trump Tariffs Disrupted Critical Coronavirus Supplies

In addition to the failure of Phase One, please note Tariffs Disrupted Medical Supplies Critical to US Coronavirus Fight.

The US-China trade war has forced US buyers to reduce purchases of medical supplies from China and seek alternative sources. US imports of Chinese medical products covered by the Trump administration’s 25 percent tariffs dropped by 16 percent in 2019 compared with two years earlier. 

It feels so unfair on the rest of the world for Trump to have all this winning.

Can’t we spread it around a bit?

Mish

Subscribe to MishTalk Email Alerts.

Subscribers get an email alert of each post as they happen. Read the ones you like and you can unsubscribe at any time.

This post originated on MishTalk.Com

Thanks for Tuning In!

Mish

Comments to this post are now closed.

25 Comments
Newest
Oldest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
ToInfinityandBeyond
ToInfinityandBeyond
5 years ago

Maybe we need to increase the tariffs.

tokidoki
tokidoki
5 years ago

This is what winning looks like.

Maximus_Minimus
Maximus_Minimus
5 years ago

Maybe the trade figures have something to do with strong dollar, which was flying since the pandemic fallout. The second thing is that the US has very little to offer in terms of consumer goods and machinery, except maybe Boeing.

Harbour
Harbour
5 years ago

It’s a pandemic. Mish is a very smart man but sometimes he lets his emotions get in the way.

BaronAsh
BaronAsh
5 years ago

If the goal is to decouple from China and the globalist networks for whom they are the manufacturing hub and begin to restructure global supply chains, then things might be doing alright. In any case, have to wait until the corona thing is over and/or there is no follow-up asymmetric attack. Right now China is making war noises, mustering troops near Hong Kong (therefore also Taiwan), attacking in India, symbiotic ally Russia is sending jets near Libya. Conventional financial metrics are a bit hard to read in what is essentially a worldwide natural disaster type situation.

Peaches11
Peaches11
5 years ago

China added a clause in the deal that in case of a pandemic it will not be able to comply with it’s promises.
Surely Mish you were aware of that clause.

rafterman
rafterman
5 years ago

Are you saying the Chinese are not keeping their promises?

marg54
marg54
5 years ago
Reply to  rafterman

Tell me it is not so! lol

ToInfinityandBeyond
ToInfinityandBeyond
5 years ago
Reply to  rafterman

Shocking.

Webej
Webej
5 years ago

Reconciliation of import/export numbers in bilateral relationships are always a source discussion in bilateral relationships, because of the way one accounts for re-exportation of component manufactures and raw materials. Even CdnUS discussions and EU countries are impacted by such accounting.

George Phillies
George Phillies
5 years ago

#1 person seriously not surprised? Trump. Xi thought he could cheat. Wrong. Outcome: Trump gave Xi the rope to hang himself, and Xi cooperated enthusiastically. Expect large increases in tariffs on trade with China, timed with respect to the election, or perhaps soon.

CaliforniaStan
CaliforniaStan
5 years ago

One problem with Xi triggering a suicide belt is we are hugging him.

Escierto
Escierto
5 years ago

Another apologist for the Great Leader, Kim Il Trump. His cult members never get tired of singing his praises.

ToInfinityandBeyond
ToInfinityandBeyond
5 years ago

Increased tariffs hurt American consumers just at the time when they are hurting financially. Sounds like a really smart move. Despite what our beloved president says tariffs are paid by American consumers.

Herkie
Herkie
5 years ago

The China situation just got a lot worse (or better depending on your view) today with Pimpeo saying Hong Kong is no longer autonomous and so will trigger sanctions.

numike
numike
5 years ago

Tech billionaires are plotting sweeping, secret plans to boost Joe Biden
Inside the experiments, data wars, and partisan news sites that Silicon Valley thinks can help Biden catch up to Trump.

Zardoz
Zardoz
5 years ago
Reply to  numike

Alternate headline:

“Business Owners Plot to Oust Moron President in Bid to Save the Civilization that Enables Their Profits”

Stuki
Stuki
5 years ago
Reply to  Zardoz

Civilization died with The Fed and income taxes. The former is simply incompatible with the two latter, period.

Even if a tiny smattering of “tech billionaires” are profitable, “profits” are hardly where their billions came from.

It really is sad, as many of those guys would be loaded regardless. It’s not as if many of them haven’t been involved in greatness.

But it truly is a testament to the utter destructiveness of financialized progressivism, that even guys the likes of Page and Brin, who as much as anyone revolutionized the world; will go to their grave having “made” far and away most of their money by way of nothing more useful than sitting there, as The Fed and government robbed innocent children into homelessness and starvation in order to obtain loot to hand the two of them.

davebarnes2
davebarnes2
5 years ago
Reply to  numike

Yes! What is the point of having the Illuminati if they don’t act?

Augustthegreat
Augustthegreat
5 years ago

When you imposed an unrealistically high bar to start with, did anybody really believe that miracle will actually happen? let alone the lockdowns.

randocalrissian
randocalrissian
5 years ago
Reply to  Augustthegreat

By sheer luck Trump should hit more than none of his goals. Wall building, paying off the entire debt (LMAO), 4, 5, even 6% GDP growth, trade magic, 15 cases in a few days will be zero, etc. When you brag to the world about everything, you’re inviting accountability, but in this case Trump excuses himself from 100% of the responsibility, as do many of his followers. Sad!

njbr
njbr
5 years ago

“It is something you’re going to be hearing about before the end of the week. Very powerfully, I think,” Trump told reporters. He said the administration would be doing something “very interesting.”

“Very powerfully.”

“Very interesting.”

How will it compare to, “Big action”?

Can’t wait for this week to end.

Zardoz
Zardoz
5 years ago
Reply to  njbr

Nothingburgers for dinner again! Yum!

ToInfinityandBeyond
ToInfinityandBeyond
5 years ago
Reply to  njbr

Trade wars are never won. It is only a question of who loses the least. This is precisely the time that world leaders should be working together to get thru this economic downturn.

Tony Bennett
Tony Bennett
5 years ago

“US exports are less than half of purchases pledged by China”

It will worsen.

offshore yuan 7.18 to $US.

My front runner for Black Swan was China devaluation.

Will it be orderly? … or not?

Decorate Your Walls with Mish Fine Art Images

Click each image to view details or purchase in the store.

Stay Informed

Subscribe to MishTalk

You will receive all messages from this feed and they will be delivered by email.