A BRIC House and an International Dollar Default by the United States

Global Isolation Impossible 

The US and EU have tried mightily to isolate Russia, even to the point of a de facto but unrecognized default on US dollars. 

Yet, total isolation is impossible, says Eurointelligence founder Wolfgang Münchau in a A BRIC, Impenetrable to Sanctions.

Remember the Brics? This acronym stood for Brazil, Russia, India, China and South Africa. They are not strategic allies of Russia. But they, and many other countries, will continue to trade with Russia.

The west, meanwhile, has taken the biggest gamble in the history of economic warfare. We have frozen the assets of the Russian central bank. 

But we did not think this through. For a central bank to freeze the accounts of another central bank is a really big deal. Economically, what this means is that the entire transatlantic west has defaulted on our most important asset: our fiat money

With this one sanction, we have done all of the following: undermined trust in the US dollar as the world’s main reserve currency; forestalled any challenge the euro might ever make; reduced the creditworthiness of our central banks; encouraged China and Russia to bypass the western financial infrastructure; and turned bitcoin into a respectable alternative transaction currency. At least the blockchain is not going to default on you.

Now consider what the Chinese will make of our sanctions. The Chinese government knows that its large exposure to US assets is equally at risk. What the US did to President Putin over Ukraine can be done to President Xi over the Uyghurs. The process of de-dollarization will take time. But China is never in a hurry.

As a direct result of these decisions, we have turned the dollar and the euro, and everything that is denominated in those currencies, into de facto risky assets. The probability of default of a dollar or euro denominated asset can no longer be credibly put at zero. With a single decision, we have created a tail risk.

Was it Worth It?

To answer that question, consider another set of questions

  • Is Putin still in power?  Yes
  • Is the EU still dependent on Russian energy? Yes
  • Did sanctions help drive Russia into China’s arms? Yes
  • Is Russia truly globally isolated? No
  • Did the Fed illegally violate its constitutional Mandate? Yes
  • Did the US force Russia into default even as Russia tries to pay creditors? Yes
  • Can Russia survive with the sanctions? Yes, easily
  • Is China the big winner in this? Yes

Münchau concludes “We are resorting to the only problem-solving method we know: kicking the can down the road. Until we hit a brick wall.”

Brick House

With that musical interlude out of the way, let’s recap where we are.

Where We Are

  1. The US did not default on interest payments, rather it stole the dollar reserves of another country. 
  2. The EU froze Putin’s and some Russian oligarch euro-denominated assets, a far less stringent, yet still severe measure.
  3. Points number one and two undermine faith in fiat currency reserves.
  4. A Russia Bond Default Coming Up and What It Means
  5. Russia Can Easily Survive, Perhaps Even Thrive, Isolated From the West
  6. US Sanction Policy Drives China Into Russia’s Loving Arms

Unprecedented Actions May Have Just Started a Global Currency Crisis

Collectively, the Unprecedented Actions May Have Just Started a Global Currency Crisis

Perhaps we are not there yet, but the stage is set. And what have we achieved but more inflation?

This post originated on MishTalk.Com.

Thanks for Tuning In!

Please Subscribe to MishTalk Email Alerts.

Subscribers get an email alert of each post as they happen. Read the ones you like and you can unsubscribe at any time.

If you have subscribed and do not get email alerts, please check your spam folder.

Mish

Subscribe to MishTalk Email Alerts.

Subscribers get an email alert of each post as they happen. Read the ones you like and you can unsubscribe at any time.

This post originated on MishTalk.Com

Thanks for Tuning In!

Mish

Comments to this post are now closed.

109 Comments
Newest
Oldest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
TheCaptain
TheCaptain
3 years ago
“what have we achieved but more inflation?”
THEY achieved the excuse for the currency event that was always going to happen anyway based on exponentially rising debt.
THEY allowed US oligarchs to blame it all on Putin.
Americans are so gullible.
FrankieCarbone
FrankieCarbone
3 years ago
Reply to  TheCaptain
Captain, they are more like “simpletons” who can only think in binary terms. Good vs. Bad, Me vs. Them, Have vs. Have-Not. I don’t think it’s gullibility but more like emotive responses based on binary choices to which the mainstream narrative excels at manipulating. You know that you’ve met one when, after you have frustrated them to no end with lateral, vs. their linear, no actually binary thinking, they lose their minds and go full ad hominem on you. 
I think “simpletons” is a more appropriate adjective to describe them. 
Lisa_Hooker
Lisa_Hooker
3 years ago
Reply to  FrankieCarbone
Nope. Americans are not gullible nor simpletons.
Americans are not paying any attention at all.
They don’t even know that this is happening.
Esclaro
Esclaro
3 years ago
In order to make sense of the comments you really have to click Ignore on all the Russian bots. 
whirlaway
whirlaway
3 years ago
Reply to  Esclaro
And of course, the definition of “Russian bot” is : anybody who does not agree with the war-hungry neocons and their equally bloodthirsty DONORcrat Party establishment friends.
FrankieCarbone
FrankieCarbone
3 years ago
Reply to  whirlaway
Disclaimer: I despise wokism and left-wing politics. Even “moderate” politics makes me sick because it assumes that one must remain within the Overton Window to be a “serious person”. That said, 42 Repulsicans voted for WW3. 
There are no good guys. We all have to swallow that bitter pill good and hard. 
Sincerely, a former die-hard Repulsican who’s brain was restarted in 2003. 
FrankieCarbone
FrankieCarbone
3 years ago
Reply to  Esclaro
Look, I don’t come here to look for arguments, particularly given the outlier-based rather bright population of posters here (for the most part) but I also cannot let an idiotic troll post like this go unpunished. This baseless accusation of yours is about as intellectually vapid, as mentally nutritious as pork rinds. I fear that you have been a lifelong victim of menticide and unfortunately, there is no rehabilitation process. Your brain is mush forever now and there’s simply no known way to fix it. You’re in juvenile black hat vs white hat mode and there’s no fixing that. God help your offspring because most victims of menticide visit this curse upon the 2nd and 3rd generations of their offspring. 
Perhaps this statement fits well enough into your binary mental processes for you to get its meaning: “The apple does not fall far from the tree”.
Say something with substance and with some real meat to back it up to demonstrate that you are indeed sentient. 
Mr. Purple
Mr. Purple
3 years ago
Let’s just ignore that the freezing of Russia’s central bank assets was a consequence of Russia initiating an aggressive war.  I would wager that any nation that refrains from aggressive war has assets safe from Federal Reserve seizure.  So there is no risk to any other nation, unless…
Jmurr
Jmurr
3 years ago
Reply to  Mr. Purple
How many aggressive wars had the US started in the last 20 years? You need 2 hands to count them. 
Mr. Purple
Mr. Purple
3 years ago
Reply to  Jmurr
That is a “Tu Quoque” fallacy, or what the Russians love to engage in, also known as “whataboutism.”
Aggressive war is a modern moral catastrophe no matter who engages in it.  Since the US is the world’s dominant superpower, at least for the time being, the US has the power to inflict punishment on those who initiate aggressive wars, whether or not the US is hypocritical in the process.  Such is the nature of politics and power.
The clear corollary is that if a nation refrains from aggressive war, its US Treasuries are secure.  It’s that simple.  No other nation need worry, just don’t start a war.  Again, I understand the US is not politically bound by this corollary, but that is reality.
lamlawindy
lamlawindy
3 years ago
Reply to  Mr. Purple
Today it’s “just don’t start a war.”  Tomorrow it could be “just don’t use coal” or “just don’t allow unfettered use of cryptocurrency.”  These actions create an incentive for other nation-states to eschew dollar-denominated assets. The point is that our (the US) govt is using measures that — while seemingly good in the short-run — will harm us in the long-term.  In an era when we were the sole superpower, the effect may have been marginal; in a multi-polar world there are alternative currencies that can be employed to circumvent the risk posed by dollar-denominated assets.
Lisa_Hooker
Lisa_Hooker
3 years ago
Reply to  Mr. Purple
Yup, don’t start a war.
Oh, and don’t elect any leaders that lack US approval.
TexasTim65
TexasTim65
3 years ago
Reply to  Mr. Purple
Unless the US just doesn’t like your government for any reason.
Exhibit A: Venezuela – assets seized
Exhibit B: Afghanistan – assets seized (I’m talking the recent seizure after the US withdrew since the Taliban have started no wars in the last 6 months that I am aware of)
I suspect that’s just the tip of the iceberg and that I’m forgetting others.
Mr. Purple
Mr. Purple
3 years ago
Reply to  TexasTim65
Well, yes.  The US can’t be prevented from defending its perceived interests. 
Re Venezuela, looks like there’s some thawing out now.  Re Afghanistan, I’m unsurprised the US is hamstringing the Taliban, the two have been enemies for decades. Iran, North Korea, yup.
I guess the problem is scalable.  Smaller nations have to really toe the line.  Larger nations, aggressive war is the line.
whirlaway
whirlaway
3 years ago
Reply to  Mr. Purple
The neocon goal is to make that smaller nation thing work on the larger nations too.  Good luck with that!   
FrankieCarbone
FrankieCarbone
3 years ago
Reply to  TexasTim65
He simply cannot see beyond his nose. His opinion is chock full of American arrogance that we have the sole right to enforce our will on any nation on Earth. 
BTW Mr. Purple. You intentionally used that Tu Quoque response as a Red Herring in order to deflect from the implicit abject hypocrisy that Jmurr was rightly calling you out for. That is that you are a hypocrite and that is among the most horrible of character traits. 
A hypocrite should never be taken seriously. Having an anchor to core principles akin to a cork in a surf, you never know when he’s gonna do a double-take carve out to support his emotionally-based stance on something, and your position is 100% emotional based on what appears a vicarious identification with US power projection. Because I have to say, your argument was completely irrational. 
FrankieCarbone
FrankieCarbone
3 years ago
Reply to  Mr. Purple
Unless your foreign policy is not aligned to bring advantage to the US and you fight them on it diplomatically. Then you’re labeled a “terr’ist” nation and the US steals your assets. 
Sorry, but your comment was as assine as “if you have nothing to hide then what do you have to worry about”. It really was. 
FrankieCarbone
FrankieCarbone
3 years ago
BTW Mish, to the point of my last question, my personal feeling on this, and that’s all I have to go on is a hunch, is that Russia will not do this. Just giving you my 2 cents on the matter but it’s circulating as you probably know. 
I think this way because Americans think its A-OK to wage economic warfare (this IS an ACT OF WAR against Russia – equivalent to a blockade) but when another nation does it to Mur’cans? Whaaaaat????? Why you’re dealing with the Greatest, Bestest People on Earth here. How dare you!
Mur’cans would BEG for a No-Fly zone and bingo, WWIII is here. I this Lazrov and Putin are smart enough to know just how dumbed-down the average Mur’can is. 
USA! USA! USA! …… barf. (I’m ashamed of my country and how they are ULTIMATELY responsible for the Ukraine mess from the beginning). 
AWC
AWC
3 years ago
Reply to  FrankieCarbone
All possibilities are on the table there Frankie, especially considering we now have a Whitehouse who’s denizens resemble a bar scene from Star Wars. 
FrankieCarbone
FrankieCarbone
3 years ago
Reply to  AWC
I guess it’s not rude to insult fictional characters. 
whirlaway
whirlaway
3 years ago
Reply to  AWC
As Warren Buffett said in a different context – buy two of everything, and pretty soon you have, not a portfolio but a zoo!
FrankieCarbone
FrankieCarbone
3 years ago
Well said. I was gonna comment here the other day regarding this. 
Mish, by now I am sure that you have heard the rumor mill, actually it’s really the speculation mill that Russia could/might demand energy payment in either rubles (to create demand for the ruble due to the EU’s addiction to Russian energy) or gold (to bust the COMEX paper markets, tailspin our overall financial markets and revalue their CB gold holdings). 
Do you have any particular thoughts on this? I see it as speculative of course but both scenarios are nuclear financial weapons against the West if they keep antagonizing The Bear. Do you think they’d possibly drop either of them on us? 
AWC
AWC
3 years ago
Reply to  FrankieCarbone
Here’s a wild speculation to ponder. China aligns with Russia, India, Central Africa, assorted ME oil producing nations etc,,,,and continues the “Construction” of The Belt and Road project, setting up a new trade platform, complete with a universal digital currency exchange system, ultimately negating its need to deal in dollars. It then packages all those treasuries up and sends them back where they came from. Too dystopian a concept? Maybe Russia dumping all its T-Promises  was a sign? 
FrankieCarbone
FrankieCarbone
3 years ago
Reply to  AWC
AWC, have you been watching the de-dollarization chess moves by the BRICS over the past 13-14 yrs? Shanghai Gold Exchange, the SCO, CIPS, SPFS (which are now linking), currency swap agreements, chumming up with the Saudis, ect?  
The reason I asked for Mish’s 2-cents on this is because it seems pretty darn clear that the East is sick of dollar hegemony and anyone using the dixie has to play “Jump Doggie Jump” every time Uncle Son of Sam demands obedience to his benefit at their expense. This article is so timely of Mish because I was thinking that Creepy Senile Joe’s handlers (let’s admit it, he’s not sentient. He’s neurologically gone…) have cut our our nose to spite our face with these insane sanctions. What kind of idiot would trash FAITH in the global reserve currency with such an action? 
The District of Criminals, aka “The Death Star on the Potomac”, regardless of which crime family has the chair of The Commission is either stupid or they are wantonly trying to destroy the United States via killing its economy. One can only speculate as to motive/reason and personally I have no clue which one it is. Both are entirely possible, given their quite obvious motivation of destroying the culture and fracturing national cohesiveness into a Balkanized State. Could they be engaging in “Creative Destruction” in order to bring in a new system that the elites find more suitable to their tastes? Only God knows. Anyone else who claims to know the truth is nothing less than delusional. 
I do believe though that the damage is done and the dollar’s time is numbered in months, if not a few brief years at best. 
But something’s really not right. I mean seriously not right with how this nation has plummeted so far, so fast. It’s unnatural. Unless of course we are undergoing the dynamics of empire collapse, which seems to me to be the most reasonable explanation. 
AWC
AWC
3 years ago
Meh, looks like a new Cold War, and a major realignment of wealth and power, (Empire?) from the NATO club to Eurasia. And all this saber rattling in the West bears an interesting resemblance to a classic Thucydides Trap. 
Starring Boris and Brandon as “Athena,” and Vlad and Xi as “Sparta.” 
Six000mileyear
Six000mileyear
3 years ago
The Russian oligarchs were never charged with a crime. The US has not formally declared a war. The executive branch overstepped its authority. So while Americans cheer because something was done, very few realize their personal belongings are now in the cross hairs of the government.
FrankieCarbone
FrankieCarbone
3 years ago
Reply to  Six000mileyear
Sadly most people think without any discernment so the thought likely never crossed anyone’s mind. Trust me, when the FED announces FEDCoin, the media will sell it as the greatest thing since the invention of the wheel and the masses will BEG for their own enslavement – due solely, and only to the perceived convenience. 
Sad society we live in, isn’t it? 
FromBrussels
FromBrussels
3 years ago
Reply to  Six000mileyear
….and these criminal developments tend to start very small….look what happened in Canada, a textbook example of democracy….. 
Lisa_Hooker
Lisa_Hooker
3 years ago
Reply to  FromBrussels
…then there’s the democracy of Germany in 1932…
FromBrussels
FromBrussels
3 years ago
Reply to  Lisa_Hooker
….So, what exactly is your message, if may ask ?  Thanks
Doug78
Doug78
3 years ago
The reserves were not stolen, they were frozen by the US and in conjunction with the EU allies and Russia will get them back if they thaw out. Central banks are always dealing with each other but if you piss them off by invading a friendly country and starting the biggest war Europe has seen since WW II then you should expect to be treated badly. To expect otherwise is magical thinking.
Putin is still in power but the war is only three weeks old.
The EU is still dependent of Russian energy but they are taking very strong steps to totally eliminate Russia as an energy provider by the end of the year. Thierry Breton said that today in public so it is official and they can do it. Frankly Europe is not going to be pushed around by a third-rate power.
Sanctions did drive Russia further into China’s arms but China was deep into Russia already and now will come out with very favorable terms. Russia will have to sell at a discount and at the price China, as their sole buyer, wants.
Russia is now isolated from over 50% of world GDP and over 80% of its high tech producers. Not something you want to be if you want to prosper.
By freezing its means to make payments it does force Russia into default which was one of the reasons the US and the EU did it. Default makes it technically possible to create liens on Russia’s assets such as gold for example. 
Russia can survive isolated but not prosper and will not be able to afford their armed forces. Russia really doesn’t make enough of the critical components to keep it afloat. 
China is a big winner in that they now have Russia over a barrel and will take her for all she’s worth. On the other hand Russia’s worth as a military partner is very much compromised. On top of it the European Nato members have understood the value of the alliance and are upping military spending which is definitely not in China’s interest. It will free up US military assets for the Pacific. Germany adding 100 billion Euro to their military budget is in itself 125% of Russian defence spending and other countries will not be left behind. The bear poked the sleeping giant and woke him up. Don’t you think it stupid to threaten a group of countries that represent over eight times your GDP and a population of 510 million to your 144 million? I do. I think it is one the the stupidest things I have ever witnessed.
Six000mileyear
Six000mileyear
3 years ago
Reply to  Doug78
Russia exported 50% more than it imported. Certainly with that kind of surplus prosperity should have happened For prosperity to happen the government would have to give up some of its centralized planning (power, authority) to let individuals re-invest profits.
Doug78
Doug78
3 years ago
Reply to  Six000mileyear
It should have been a good way to finance the expansion of the economy but unfortunately the resource exports were so lucrative that the sector took more and more of the investment leaving the high-tech sectors starved. One of the most devastating consequences was that it caused a very large brain drain since those who wanted to work in those areas had to emigrate in order to do so. The resource sector grew and grew but ate the sectors that could have really produced wealth. As an example Apple, Microsoft, Alphabet and Amazon have collectively as much cash as Russia has cash reserves before the freeze. The Russian oligarchs and Putin set up a rentier economy and skimmed off as much as they could without instituting any economic policies for the future. There are almost no dynamic companies left in Russia. That is the great crime and they will be known in history for it.
thimk
thimk
3 years ago
Reply to  Doug78
USA is not at war with russia – why implement wartime sanctions ?  USA threw the baby out with the bath water.  This is not a good precedent . What country would borrow dollars if your ability to repay in dollars is restricted ?.  Good narrative augmentation . 
Doug78
Doug78
3 years ago
Reply to  thimk
There are increments between total peace to total war. Putting on sanctions is not an act of war. Voluntary embargos are not either. 
“What country would borrow dollars if your ability to repay in dollars is restricted ?” You have the misconception that this is limited to dollars. It is not. Euros, Pounds and Yen are also included. That leaves for Russia little choice of currencies to deal in. The Yuan is only 2.66% of the world’s foreign exchange reserve and is only partially convertible so there is a limit to what Russia, if China wants, can do. Eventually it might happen but it is far from there yet.
FromBrussels
FromBrussels
3 years ago
Reply to  Doug78
may I remind you that people NOT brainwashed by msm propaganda , are very much aware that this conflict was 100% provoked by the US ?  
Doug78
Doug78
3 years ago
Reply to  FromBrussels
What’s msn?
Jack
Jack
3 years ago
Reply to  FromBrussels
What is msm. I see you mention them a lot.
FromBrussels
FromBrussels
3 years ago
Reply to  Jack
wouldn t know…. but judging by your comment they are doing a good job,  keeping you deluded and stupid in other words ….. 
StukiMoi
StukiMoi
3 years ago
Reply to  Doug78
Not sure what you consider a “high tech producer”, but they are mostly all in China by now. Or at least Asia. Some in Israel, and Russia itself, as pertains to military goods.
Aviation “currently” being a notable exception. But Chinese OEMs aren’t lagging that far behind anymore. After all, it’s not THAT hard to catch up to where the US was in 1965. Which is, where the US still is today (I’m being generous)….. Russia is a big country. Too big, and tundra plagued, to maintain a freeway net covering. Ergo, a big aviation market.
Other than that, there is little “tech” produced in the West, which can’t be very closely matched in China/Asia, once competition disappears. The West has lots of legacy producers. But very little ability to produce “tech” which Asia cannot replace rather closely. At a lower cost even, in many cases.
Also, 50% of GDP, has a lot more to do with GDP being measured in monopoly money, than anything more solid. As long as you get to pretend that Some mediocre dilettante putting together a Powerpoint presentation; to an illiterate on Fed Welfare who knows any loss will be covered by the Fed and junta; just “created” a multibillion dollar batterytoy “startup” which is “worth” more than entire Chinese cities build in the same timespan; then, yes, I suppose you can pretend that you are, like, really rich and powerful and visionary and important and stuff. Building cities is hard, though. Takes resources. Powerpoint presentations is something anyone can do. Takes no resources at all.
Lisa_Hooker
Lisa_Hooker
3 years ago
Reply to  StukiMoi
Oh, I dunno. Getting the dissolves and wipes looking really impressive is not easy. Takes time.
Billy
Billy
3 years ago
One thing a war does is it builds values within it’s citizens. When you feel that you’ve almost lost everything, everything around you becomes more precious. Pride for your country becomes strong. People start caring for people they don’t know. Especially for the elderly.
I don’t know about you but I miss those days.
AWC
AWC
3 years ago
Reply to  Billy
This ain’t your grandfather’s war. This one has every possibility of culminating in tens of thousands of mushroom clouds. Kinda like a big weenie roast, where earths inhabitants are on the menu. 
Lisa_Hooker
Lisa_Hooker
3 years ago
Reply to  AWC
I doubt very much that we will achieve more than a few hundred mushroom clouds. Maybe very low thousands.
Casual_Observer2020
Casual_Observer2020
3 years ago
If these BRIC countries were so smart how come they didn’t come up with their own banking system. They are supposedly full of geniuses. I’ve been to 3 of 4 BRIC countries and was born in one of them. These are countries that no one in their right mind would go to live in. These emerging markets never become developed because they don’t have have liberty or freedom. That also applies to the democracies because they fail to stand up for individual property rights in their courts. Literally nothing in the modern ages was invented by the BRICs but they do do a lot of stealing. They also have a ton of people who keep wanting to come to the US. Odd.
whirlaway
whirlaway
3 years ago
I don’t think anybody has any illusions that the BRIC countries getting more powerful will somehow suddenly be beneficial to all of their citizens.  The common man in any of those countries will continue to suffer in the same way that he is suffering now.   

In fact, about the only major change that will happen is that the average Joe in US will crash down to the level of the average folks in any of those countries.   

StukiMoi
StukiMoi
3 years ago
“..because they don’t have have liberty or freedom. “
“… because they fail to stand up for individual property rights in their courts.”
You mean, like the US? Stealing bank deposits, “confiscating” this and that, ambulance chasers rapaciously grabbing anything they want… All with the help of completely; 100%; in no way whatsoever any better than North Korean ones even, and much worse than either Russian and Chinese ones; kangaroo courts which serve NO other purpose than facilitating theft by the connected and regime pliant, from everyone else.
The US used to be different. Now, it’s not. Not even in the slightest. Hence, all the pathologies you mentioned as integral to the BRIC experience, now applies, full force, in the US as well. With the only difference being: The US also follows you around the world robbing you. The BRICS don’t (Possible exceptions being a few, very limited cases of Polonium justice by the Russians, and similar albeit less spectacular by the Chinese).
Casual_Observer2020
Casual_Observer2020
3 years ago
Let’s do nothing when America gets invaded. The libertarian answer is always the same. Do nothing. They are pacifists at heart.
RonJ
RonJ
3 years ago
Göring replied: “Oh, that is all well and good, but, voice or no voice, the people can always be brought to the bidding of the leaders. That is easy.
All you have to do is tell them they are being attacked and denounce the pacifists for lack of patriotism and exposing the country to danger. It works the same way in any country.”
The leaders have your number.
Doug78
Doug78
3 years ago
Reply to  RonJ
Didn’t work out well for him, did it? 
Democritus
Democritus
3 years ago
Reply to  Doug78
And neither will it for Casual_O,,,
Doug78
Doug78
3 years ago
Reply to  Democritus
Meaning what exactly??
RonJ
RonJ
3 years ago
Reply to  Doug78
How well did it work out for the 60 million killed in WW2, after being played by the leaders?
Mr. Purple
Mr. Purple
3 years ago
Libertarianism is a spectrum, so individuals vary.  But most libertarians adhere to the principle of non-aggression, which does not preclude self-defense as pacifism does. 
That being said, America has not been invaded and is vanishingly unlikely to be in any imaginable future, so we will never know how libertarians would react to such. And it should go without saying that Ukraine is not America and therefore none of our f@<king business — that is a libertarian opinion.
whirlaway
whirlaway
3 years ago
Ukraine is not part of America.   If you think it is, parachute yourself into that place.   Some of us here would be willing to pay for that trip!
vanderlyn
vanderlyn
3 years ago
Reply to  whirlaway
you mean i cannot catch the 2 or 3 train from brooklyn to ukraine?   jesus,  the idiot box media makes it seem like ukraine is like just  venturing to not too far away lands like NJ or CT………….
thimk
thimk
3 years ago
yes – looks like a return to the barter system . Tragic , tragic mistake for USA  to freeze Rusky reserves . Did EU do so also ?? .  
thimk
thimk
3 years ago
Reply to  thimk
No EU did not freeze Russia reserves , just assets as article states . missed it .   
Columbo
Columbo
3 years ago
Besides the BRIC countries you can also add Israel and Mexico to that list. They’re trying to tread the neutral line.
Mish
Mish
3 years ago
Reply to  Columbo
Good Point
Doug78
Doug78
3 years ago
Reply to  Columbo
Israel said it will impose sanctions on the Russian oligarchs. They have to tread lightly because they have this understanding with Russia about Syria and needs Russia’s neutrality in bombing their enemies in that country.  
Casual_Observer2020
Casual_Observer2020
3 years ago
Reply to  Columbo
Mexico is so neutral that it is sending Russian citizens who have left Russia to the US seeking asylum. Mexico is a joke of a country.
vanderlyn
vanderlyn
3 years ago
Reply to  Columbo
israel sees hand writing on wall.  as US pulls out of mideast with our tail between legs,  and we are collapsing internally and internationally,  they need to make nice with world.   or they will be steam rolled into the sea.   i believe the usa did israel a big disservice.   using them for half a century under the guise of protector.    i vote in multiple countries and hear this in my interactions………….i think amerikans last to get this.   but doesn’t matter.    israel will play nice with russia and china.   they must.  to survive another 50 or 1000 years.    
whirlaway
whirlaway
3 years ago
Reply to  vanderlyn
Also, don’t forget that the neo-Nazi groups that the Russians are fighting in Ukraine, are virulently anti-Jewish.   
Naphtali
Naphtali
3 years ago
Reply to  Columbo
Turkey
Lisa_Hooker
Lisa_Hooker
3 years ago
Reply to  Naphtali
Nah. Turducken.
Democritus
Democritus
3 years ago
I heard the song before learning English, wondering if they sang “how” or “aw”… Okay “Brick House” – learned something just now!
TexasTim65
TexasTim65
3 years ago
Reply to  Democritus
Yeah, they slowly drawl out the words in the song so that instead of saying ‘brick house’ as you would in normal conversation it comes out as ‘Brick *pause* how *pause* sa’
selimtk
selimtk
3 years ago
Would you prefer we fired?
Freebees2me
Freebees2me
3 years ago
Mish,
Great synopsis of the train wreck we are all watching in slow motion.
(Small typo: following the quote you referred to “Manchin”. Clearly you meant Münchau).  Although Manchin would agree.
Peace!
Mish
Mish
3 years ago
Reply to  Freebees2me
Thanks 
Fixed
StukiMoi
StukiMoi
3 years ago
The US central bank and administration already did the same thing, stole, Afghanistan’s deposits. That happened over a month ago. And in that case, it’s not even just a nominal freeze. But rather outright stealing it. Then handing half to the ambulance chasing piles of garbage that the current US terror regime can always be counted on to rob others for the benefit of. And the other half to equally useless dilettantes who like to preen around pretending they have ever, in their entire worthless lives, done anything of benefit to anyone at all, other than themselves.
Stealing is what the US government and its central bank does. And furthermore, it is also the absolute only thing either of them ever do. No yabuts of the “but they do something useful as well” kind. None. Just theft, harassment and destruction. Without any exception whatsoever.
Tony Bennett
Tony Bennett
3 years ago
Reply to  StukiMoi
“Stealing is what the US government and its central bank does.”
Absolutely.
Looking back at the GFC just a few “rules”  USG/FR broke to protect the “chosen” at US taxpayer’s expense:  Bernanke bought GSE mbs.  At time a fedgov guarantee was “implicit” … Ben made it “EXPLICIT”.  Federal Reserve opened its Discount Window to every tom, dick, and harry (GE and Harley Davidson two of the many).  Of course, the big enchilada was USG stepping in to take over AIG (so Goldman Sachs could get 100 cents on the dollar).
Jmurr
Jmurr
3 years ago
Reply to  Tony Bennett
“When plunder becomes a way of life for a group of men in a society, over the course of time they create for themselves a legal system that authorizes it and a moral code that glorifies it “. Frederic Bastiat. 
Maximus_Minimus
Maximus_Minimus
3 years ago
There was once an organization called non-aligned movement which encompassed all countries not part of NATO or the Warsaw pact. It held its own gatherings. This lost its meaning with the end of cold war, and the dissolution of the Warsaw pact. There was only one peculiar outlier left behind.
Sweet memories, when only the banana republics had interest rates below inflation, and all the money fled to rationally managed Western financial institutions.
William Janes
William Janes
3 years ago
Unimpressive analysis by Mr. EuroIntelligence:  of what value is South Africa or Brazil to Russia?  The BRIC meme was never more than a silly investment meme.   As for China, how is the Russian disaster in Ukraine of value to them, other them making Russia weaker versus China.   China is already plump with Oil supplies.  They signed a much vaunted agreement with Iran last year trading Iranian oil for Chinese goods.   China is already amply supplied with oil.  As for Russia thriving under these sanctions, ask yourself, why would Russia not be thriving before with their trade with Europe.  Russia will not be thriving.    International monetary agreements may change but then they would be changing after Russia’s invasion of Ukraine.    A separation of economic systems would be in order anyway.
Mish
Mish
3 years ago
Reply to  William Janes
You are correct about one thing. The BRIC meme was silly. But Eurointelligence would likely agree.
So despite being correct about one tiny thing, you miss the entire big picture, including the discussion of survive vs thrive. 
Columbo
Columbo
3 years ago
Reply to  William Janes
And when they met during the Olympics they agreed to build a pipeline from Russia to China. That would make them even plumper I guess.
KidHorn
KidHorn
3 years ago
Reply to  William Janes
Russia is critical for BRI. A lot more world trade in the future is going to go through central Asia. Not over the sea like it is now.
Tony Bennett
Tony Bennett
3 years ago
“With this one sanction, we have done all of the following: undermined trust in the US dollar as the world’s main reserve currency”
Hardly.
“and turned bitcoin into a respectable alternative transaction currency. At least the blockchain is not going to default on you.”
Yeah, well … US government at anytime could ban transactions in bitcoin to protect $US, which by chance about to Roar!
United States 25% of planet’s GDP.  They call the shots.  At least till WW3.
Mish
Mish
3 years ago
Reply to  Tony Bennett
Agree that Wolfgang overplayed Bitcoin. 
A small error in an overall great post.
Casual_Observer2020
Casual_Observer2020
3 years ago
Reply to  Tony Bennett
It’s more than 25%. That was before covid. The world cannot survive without the US consumer. 
Mr. Purple
Mr. Purple
3 years ago
Reply to  Tony Bennett
I think it might be time for Mish to recap the $US reserve status criteria again so we’re all immunized from this ridiculous idea there will be a replacement reserve currency in our lifetimes.
KidHorn
KidHorn
3 years ago
Reply to  Tony Bennett
Our GDP is based off an inflated service sector. Many other countries, like China, is primarily based off goods production. Not all production is the same.
Dutoit
Dutoit
3 years ago
Has this something to do with other expropriations, but against citizens of western countries, as did Trudeau in Canada ?
Scooot
Scooot
3 years ago

It’s common sense isn’t it. If you put your money in a bank for safe keeping, and that bank confiscates somebody else’s money because they can, you’re likely to look for another home for your  own money. 

Mish
Mish
3 years ago
Reply to  Scooot
Yes, that home will be for China to hold more commodities and fewer dollars despite the pro-cyclical nature of it.
Scooot
Scooot
3 years ago
Reply to  Mish
Yes I agree. China and others will gradually reduce they’re holdings of Treasuries, the yield doesn’t matter vis a vie access. I also think like minded countries will speed up the development of their central bank digital currencies to facilitate trade amongst themselves. 
Captain Ahab
Captain Ahab
3 years ago
Reply to  Scooot
How will Zimbabwe, for example, having its own digital  currency (and inherent volatility) facilitate trade with other countries?  If anything it pushes the world toward a stable unit of exchange–held in high regard and nationally neutral. I wonder what yellow metal might be?
Scooot
Scooot
3 years ago
Reply to  Captain Ahab
Well I didn’t necessarily mean every country, but let’s say some mutual allies such as China, Russia and India might be happy to use any one of their own for trade between themselves for example.  In any case I’m only speculating about it. 
As for the yellow metal, yes I agree, weightings in this will probably increase, plus other commodities but I doubt it will be used as a standard as in the past. 
TexasTim65
TexasTim65
3 years ago
Reply to  Captain Ahab
The problem with the Yellow Metal is that most of it is physically held in London and New York in the names of other countries. So even if countries wished to trade it back and forth London or NY could easily veto the trade or seize someone’s gold holdings in the same way they did foreign reserves.
Scooot
Scooot
3 years ago
Reply to  TexasTim65
And Switzerland. They don’t need to hold it in N/Y or London though, or trade it on western exchanges. I’d envisage business developing in non western exchanges amongst mutually interested parties. 
Doug78
Doug78
3 years ago
Reply to  Scooot
Switzerland is in the sanctions group breaking their neutral tradition in this case. That’s how important this is seen by just about everybody. 
vanderlyn
vanderlyn
3 years ago
Reply to  TexasTim65
i respectfully disagree.   a gold backed ruble with convertability in moscow, shanghai, singapore, brazil……….would work like a charm.    just like the UK pound and countless others before,   a nation only needs a small fraction of gold,  as most holders of currency will not convert every day.  or ever.    i’d suspect as the EU realizes amerika is failing fast now and screwing them up on gas access………….the europeans will be fine trading in a gold backed currency.   hell i could see the euro being gold backed in a few years.    it’s really not so difficult.   has been done for thousands of years.    the US could even do it.   i was always betting on russians or germans or chinese or amerikans to go to gold backed currency again in my lifetime.    
Scooot
Scooot
3 years ago
Reply to  Mish
The only thing I’d add is that this would have probably happened anyway, as the threat of freezing central bank reserves and cancelling swift access has been building over the past few years. Action over Ukraine has just been a new catalyst. 
StukiMoi
StukiMoi
3 years ago
Reply to  Mish
Holding deposits in the US, will also become politicized.
Juntas hoping to receive preferential treatment by the US in exchange for publicly bending over and regurgitate its propaganda, will publicly do so. While those wishing to retain some independence will stay as far away as they can.
It’s funny to listen to the Russians now jumping through all kinds of hoops, in order to reassure people they are still doing the very-very-very-very-we-really-are best that sanctions allow them to, wrt “honoring their obligations.” Despite simply defaulting on anything Western and nationalizing it being perfectly understandable. And I’m pretty sure it’s not out of some great concern for justice, fairness and impartiality.
But rather them trying to cash in, if only a little, on the uncertainty brought about by this latest low in Fed theft. Very, very few countries, will want to find themselves singularly beholden to run-amuck, theft funded US social justice warriors and other hysterics, backed up by the ever more rapacious US ambulance chasing choir, as far as their currency reserves are concerned.  Today, it’s Russia on account of Ukrainie. Tomorrow it’s someone else, for not having enough transgender women on the board of Gaia saving battery car “startups” (funded, no doubt by Fed connected bankster trash…). One way or the other, countries, like people, will want to hedge their bets. Meaning, some share of reserves may even end up deposited with the Putin gang. If nothing else, over there it will be backed by some natural reserves, not just hot air.
StukiMoi
StukiMoi
3 years ago
Reply to  Scooot
What was also common, back when such a thing as people not 100% indoctrinated into pliant idiocy walked The West, was that most people realized the best, and only appropriate, thing to do with banksters who arbitrarily took depositors’ funds, was to simply, literally, string them up and hang them.
Captain Ahab
Captain Ahab
3 years ago
Reply to  StukiMoi
I am waiting for the day when the impoverished masses erect guillotines in The Mall and cut off the heads of every (central) banker, and the politicians who enabled the theft.
TexasTim65
TexasTim65
3 years ago
Reply to  Captain Ahab
Won’t happen till the people go hungry because they can’t afford food. That’s when the French started lopping off heads.
Jojo
Jojo
3 years ago
Reply to  TexasTim65
People in NK are hungry.  Doesn’t seem to be working there.
TexasTim65
TexasTim65
3 years ago
Reply to  Jojo
True. So that means one or both of the following is true.
1) They are hungry but not starving (ie they are being fed enough to live)
2) Of those that are starving, there aren’t enough to matter (ie rise up in masses and lop off heads)
Maximus_Minimus
Maximus_Minimus
3 years ago
Reply to  TexasTim65
Hungry, combined with arrogance of the ruling class, and censorship.
The really downtrodden never did rise against the ruling class; they tread rather on their own.
The new betters are the true brains behind any change.
vanderlyn
vanderlyn
3 years ago
Reply to  TexasTim65
peasants are passive unless they miss 9 meals.   calories so cheap and plentiful to produce.  nobody is going hungry in pax dumbfuc*istan for centuries to come.     i could trap my limit 350lb hogs,  with a dozen donuts and a bear trap in all 4 states and many big cities and rural towns i have lived
vanderlyn
vanderlyn
3 years ago
Reply to  Scooot
russia could go to a gold backed ruble in a year or few.   no problemo.   what old is new.   nothing complicated about it.   
StukiMoi
StukiMoi
3 years ago
Reply to  vanderlyn
Almost all (aside from those who simply don’t have the ability to reliably protect physical anything) countries could.
And all their populations would benefit immensely from them doing so. Including the US.
Not just that, but early adopters would benefit massively: In the early days, Gold would, net, flow their way. Then its holders would benefit massively, as others follow suit and demand went through the roof. It doesn’t take that large a share of the world’s population using Gold, before non-location-dependent savings would flow into it from everywhere.
The only reason you are not seeing any country do it, is that ALL juntas are afraid of losing their asymmetric ability to easily steal, which is what debasable “money” represent. The Kremlin gang included. They could easily suck up massive foreign reserve deposits, as well as commercial investment, by Gold denominating deposits and providing a huge market where prices and taxes are quoted in Gold. All they’d have to do, was demonstrate that they are reliable stewards of the funds, come what may. Which would take the Kremlin all of a week, since they could just declare some third world country a hobgoblin and invade them, yet still provide them access to their funds.
But, so much of current totalitarian regimes’ power and influence, stems from being able to force others to work hard and behave as the regime says, in exchange for something which the regime can simply print in unlimited quantities; and hand to those they like; entirely without cost nor constraint. Just look at the US: People living hand to mouth in the street while being forced to pick cotton 14 hours a day to pay arbitrary mandates and “rent.” Then being whipped, which is OK as long as someone regime connected in a clown robe arbitrarily deems it so, if they say something, or act, uppity. The Kremlin want that as well. They want it so badly, they are willing to forego all the benefits of having a real currency which others demand, simply in order to retain that easy-peasy way to steal and enslave.
Some smaller countries may have their rulers close enough to the population, and may eventually end up with a population sufficiently literate, that they do convert to Gold (or bitcoin, or whatever). But then, that’s what the Russian and American (and later on the Chinese no doubt) militaries, propaganda machines and well indoctrinated populations of reliably illiterate dupes, exists to “correct……”
KidHorn
KidHorn
3 years ago
If you exclude Asia, Africa, and South America, Russia is completely isolated. A new Berlin wall is being put up, but it’s more likely to go around the US and their allies.
Christoball
Christoball
3 years ago
I never thought the war was going to be the Back Swan Event, but certainly the sanctions could.
Captain Ahab
Captain Ahab
3 years ago
Reply to  Christoball
No, the swan is back!
My favorite low-probability high-impact event is the Fed goes (technically) bankrupt when it is unable to stem increases in the interest rate.
vanderlyn
vanderlyn
3 years ago
Reply to  Captain Ahab
the plan of the bankers long term,  who own the fed, has been to sell the fed to the us treasury.  let the peasants pay for their bad paper they stuck on fed balance sheet.   this is the bankers life preservers on titanic.    a known known for any student us central bank history……………….the fed ain’t our first rodeo.  if you count the confederate dollars,  the fed is our 4th central bank.    as usual in world history,  the peasants will pay, in blood sweat and tears.   

Stay Informed

Subscribe to MishTalk

You will receive all messages from this feed and they will be delivered by email.