I see 10 year Treasuries >4% within twelve months. The inflation figures will drive some of it, but the two biggest sources of demand are going to turn to supply. Uncle Sam has been monetising bond issues for years, but is turning that tap off. Now China will want to move its reserves away from the dollar. Even not buying any more will hurt yields bady, but my guess is they’ll start selling. This always was the ultimate sanction against the west – they may decide now is the time to play their ace.
blacklisted
2 years ago
We also put a blockade on Japan prior to Pearl Harbor and look what happened. Desperate people and countries do desperate things when they are desperate.
Gold can be confiscated too – it’s happened before and it can happen again. One cannot jump on a plane anymore with their gold anymore, and it can be deemed money laundering to keep it in a safety deposit box, making it easy to confiscate (civil asset forfeiture).
BDR45
2 years ago
As I remember, Russia supplies about 30% of the world’s fertilizer. Crops without fertilizer have reduced yields. Reduced yields usually means prices rise, reducing the quality of life for many people.
How do you know that 100% of all fertilizer production was in demand previously to any Russian cutout? There’s probably more than enough excess supply available or capable of coming onboard to cover any shortfall.
Russia built an economy like a fortress but the pain is real
By The Associated Press
10 March 2022
Western sanctions are dealing a severe blow to Russia’s economy. The ruble is plunging, foreign businesses are fleeing and sharply higher prices are in the offing. Familiar products may disappear from stores, and middle-class achievements like foreign vacations are in doubt.
Beyond the short-term pain, Russia’s economy will likely see a deepening of the stagnation that started to set in long before the invasion of Ukraine.
As un-PC as it may currently seem to certain Twitter-addicts: same eventually, and increasingly, becomes true if people don’t cross.
George_Phillies
2 years ago
“Russia produces 3.9 metric tons of aluminium” Point is well made, but I think there is something wrong with this number, for example a bunch of trailing zeros.
thimk
2 years ago
So anybody out there know where we are going to get russian replacement oil/products from??
Biden is living In a USA bygone era (this isn’t post wwII) . How today USA rules: mandates,restrictions , embargoes, sanctions, unilateral executive orders , tariffs, cancellations, penalties . Pretty soon we will have no one left to sanction but ourselves
First off, it isn’t that much oil. And some of that isn’t oil, its refined products like gasoline. But we could easily get it from Canada. Too bad we didn’t build the goddamn KXL Pipeline. Another Biden bad call.
But compared to the loss of Russian uranium that looks baked-in to this cake, the oil is laughably unimportant. Uranium spot has jumped from the low $40’s a week ago to almost $60 today. Russia has been selling us cheap enriched uranium from decommissioned warheads for many years….and they refine the uranium we get from Kazakstan. The sanctions were not really all that well thought out, if you ask me.
Anderson Cooper on Anderson Cooper 360, 3/9/2022 ~9:25pm EST
“Everyday we are in the Ukraine it becomes more & more apparent how important it is, in addition to all their other needs, for people here to simply be seen and have their voices heard, people want you, around the world to know what is happening here, they want you to see it & hear it, they want you to hear their stories, Ukrainians with relatives living in Russia telling them what they are going through only to be told by an uncle or parent or close Russian friend “no that’s not really happening at all”. Imagine what that is like!”
Too funny. Imagine if CNN were to step back in time and compare Anderson Coopers quote above to how CNN censored all voices in the Covid pandemic that questioned or did not agree with the Covid narrative as presented by the CDC, FDA and St. Fauci, where anchor people, the CNN MD corps and various so-called pundits were telling everyone that any other POV was incorrect, inaccurate, foolish and misinformed. The American people were not allowed to have accurate info that would have helped them make informed decisions.
Isn’t that the same as what Cooper is alluding to vis-a-vis Ukraine in his quote above?
Depends how you look at it. S&P is at roughly the same level as last June, the Dow same as last March, so most people who’ve bought since then are out of the money. 🙂
RonJ
2 years ago
“But guess what happens if everyone starts hoarding things that others need?”
Senator Warren will be calling for windfall profits taxes on those selling them, like she just did for the oil companies.
ColoradoAccountant
2 years ago
I totally agree with Mish. I have read several articles that the sanctions put an end to the US dollar as the reserve currency. The message was clear that the US could not be trusted to hold a country’s reserves. Everyone with dollar reserves will liquidate them over the next few years. Countries will be looking for assets that hurt when you drop them on your foot as reserves for their currency.
Publishing an article doesn’t end the dollar’s reserve status. Our $30T economy still rules over all. I’ll take the other side of that bet until a new reserve currency is adopted.
Yes. The debt is mostly to ourselves. Wiping off the Russian and Chinese debt is a start. Both of these countries are bankrupt of something they have never and will never create — freedom and liberty.
“Freedom” . . .yes we have the “freedom” for little boys to wack off their privates, take hormone blockers and become a “girl”, or have adult men say they are a “woman” and beat all the women in sports.Yeah that’s real freedom there . . .
Webej
2 years ago
Mish, my problems with MishTalk/Chrome have disappeared, without even exiting the program….
Every time you need to repeat a punishment, you are halving your authority … You have authority when they do as told; punishment simply underscores that you are desperate to reclaim the lost ground after they think you are not worth heeding.
vanderlyn
2 years ago
awesome outline of a complicated and horrible move on the part of US central bank. timberrrrrrrrr. i hear the sound of another empire falling.
Bam_Man
2 years ago
This effectively marks the end of the $USD’s “Reserve Currency” status.
Any asset that can be forfeited/rendered inaccessible at the whim of the custodian is by definition NOT a “Reserve Asset”.
Ron Cataldi
2 years ago
Wow this is terrible… for Republican candidates. With Russian funds frozen, how will they fund their campaigns?
As if – no other country pours money into US elections – no other party takes any foreign money – there is no other way to launder money than direct donations
One side takes money from Russia, the other side from China. Whose interest do they represent? Certainly not the people who voted them in. Time to take off the rose colored glasses of your favorite cult.
ohno
2 years ago
Talk about going to hell in a handbasket.
Jojo
2 years ago
“In one quick order the Fed electronically rendered Russia’s foreign dollar reserves worthless, or at least unusable for now. “
Sometimes you just got to do what you got to do.
As for SA, wait until they come begging for spare parts maintenance assistance for their USA planes & armaments. The price will be a lot higher. But of course, once we get fusion power working, SA monarchs will be back to riding around the sands of their country on camels. Their oil reserves will be worthless.
That isn’t allowed? There are times when the ends justify the means.
Scooot
2 years ago
Presumably the reserves will be unfrozen at some point. In the meantime if Russia wants to access them couldn’t Russia do some sort of reserve swap with say China? EG China sells treasuries and USD from their reserves on behalf of Russia, and Russia provides China with some sort of security in exchange, oil, Gold or whatever. Or something like this?
China could but then a swap has two sides and if China sees Russia as a counterparty risk then they would hesitate to use it. For example if part of Russia’s reserves have a lien on them through legal matters provoked by the invasion then China would not have a swap but a gift to Russia.
Walter batjer
2 years ago
Legal or not Kyle Bass suggested this as a sanction against China I believe during DHT admin, so it’s an idea that’s been floating
hypothetically until now.
Freebees2me
2 years ago
These bans are going to end sooooo f-ing badly it’s not even comprehensible.
The US (via the Fed) is torching global trade. The trust is gone.
But it would still be almost unthinkably economically self destructive, for Beijing to kill the Golden Goose that Taiwan represent to them.
Whatever the Chicoms may think of the ultimate relative merits of resource allocation the Chinese way vs the Taiwanese way; there is no even remotely possible scenario, where being able to pick up a hint or two about something; from someone so culturally close and connected, yet who simultaneously face such a different business environment; is anything but a huge boon.
Taiwan will never, ever, be in any position to, in any way, threaten China. It’s too small to even account for anything like a “brain drain” away from the mainland. Yet, by being different in key areas, it allows slightly different solutions to scientific, economic and other problems to thrive, which would not have done so in China (as well as vice versa. Diversity really is a benefit…). Which is something Beijing, given the sheer amount of ties between the two, will then be the first to benefit from.
Even back when the Bolsheviks were dreaming of a world wide Communist revolution, their economists still realised they would need to leave at least New Zeeland capitalistic: After all, they would have to have somewhere to get the appropriate relative prices of goods to use in their calculations from….. The utter folly of Beijing rocking a setup as lucky and beneficial for them as Taiwan, is so obvious that I almost can’t imagine Xi and pals are, deep down, in favor of doing so. But then, perhaps commies will be commies……..
I don’t think China will invade unless the hawks in the US provoke it.
They have infinite patience and time is on their side. Besides, the least they might want is to inflate more tensions.
They watch and learn what to expect as the West throw hook, line, and sinker into the fight.
They are developing their domestic technology for photolithography (ADSL replacement), and the TSMC technology can best be acquired by poaching Taiwanese expertise.
Anon1970
2 years ago
I am actually very well supplied with TP. I double ordered from Walmart by mistake back in 2020 which carried me through the worst of the pandemic and noticed a great offering of TP in late 2021 which I took advantage of.
Casual_Observer2020
2 years ago
But guess what happens if everyone starts hoarding things that others need?
—
Need ? Or want ? I think you have this all confused. There are plenty of people surviving just fine without a computer or cell phone. The world survived just fine before gold or rare earth metals
In the olden days, average life spans were much shorter than they are today. Infant mortality was much higher and a higher percentage of the workforce was engaged in life shortening occupations.
One data point: Wind the clock back 20 years and I’d be dead. Cancer. Wind the clock a hair more back and my wife and kids would not be alive. Childbirth issues.
It’s hard to see how much better life is now than, say, 40 years ago. Someone in their 20’s in 1830 in the US could think in 1870, “Sure the railroad and telegraph are cool, but they aren’t really needed.”
Casual_Observer2020
2 years ago
China started hoarding rare earth metals a long time ago . Anyone who didn’t know this hasn’t been paying attention.
Dean_70
2 years ago
This is the most devastating ban yet. They crossed the line with this one: link to news.yahoo.com
Chinese will eat anything that moves. They justify and make the things more mentally palatable by ascribing aphrodisiac powers to their consumption. They need to do this because large parts of China still suffer from hunger, which is why one should take their claimed economic numbers with a grain of salt..
The finishing touches have been applied to shape the economy into a completely centrally controlled system, giving new meaning to the phrase “Political Economy.” In this brave new world of Command and Control, the only thing that matters is, the central planner’s agenda.
For analogous purposes, open the history books to around 1917, and the Bolshevik period of the formation of the Soviet Union, but you might also take a peek at the events that took place around 1933 in Germany, just for a contrary perspective.
So, buy the dip? Sure, if Nancy, Hunter and the Fed governor’s “Cunado’s” are doing the same. Invest using “fundamental” or “technical” analysis methods? Do y’all feel lucky? Because, you are playing against the house, and the house always wins.
“We are not at a full blown crisis stage yet. And perhaps we do not get there this time.”
…
Likely, wishful thinking. Events are speeding up … and decisions being made without full understanding of potential consequences.
March 8 (Reuters) – Chinese companies that defy U.S. restrictions against exporting to Russia may be cut off from American equipment and software they need to make their products, U.S. Commerce Secretary Gina Raimondo told the New York Times.
The U.S. could “essentially shut” down Semiconductor Manufacturing International Corp link to reuters.com or any Chinese companies defying U.S. sanctions by continuing to supply chips and other advanced technology to Russia, Raimondo said in an interview published on Tuesday.
The Federal Reserve is only doing what it did just before and during World War II. During that conflict the Fed cut off the ability of the Axis powers to use their currency reserves in the same manor and made working with Axis banks and companies everywhere in the unoccupied countries “toxic”. It also manipulated the metals and precious metals markets to that end. After the war the Fed reverted to its normal practices. The Fed today is on a war footing and are using the tools it has used before and more to help win it. That’s all.
If one is really interested in the real worth of precious metals in a total breakdown then you should read accounts of the Siege of Sarajevo 1992.
There weren’t any currency reserves in the 2nd world war. Everyone was still on a gold standard and Breton Woods didn’t come unto play until 1944.
The US did business with Germany right up until it entered the war in Dec 41. Germany also continued to do business throughout the war with neutral countries (Sweden, Switzerland, Spain etc).
The only meaningful thing the US did was stop selling oil to Japan which resulted in Pearl Harbor.
US foreign policy in the first half of the 20th century was similar to Switzerland’s today: Neutrality.
Then as now money was not gold or silver but accounting balances. At the time they were written on paper and not electronic although large sums were “wired” by undersea cable. The Fed kept gold from many nations in vaults and payments were made by accounting marks on paper rather than actual transfers of gold. Today is not that much different than then when it comes to accounting for financial transfers. It’s just faster.
That all may be true. But unlike today, you can’t cut someone off the ‘Swift’ payment system. Countries were free to trade directly without US interference. All that could be locked up was Gold in US vaults that were on account for Germany, Japan or Italy. That’s vastly different than today’s payments that run through the US Swift system.
Also, all the Axis countries effectively defaulted 100% on all debts when they lost the war. The West, other than the US ended up massively in debt while Germany and Japan walked away debt free. That’s why France and Britain went from world powers to also rans over night.
ha ha ha. i’ve been trading for decades quite successfully with little effort. i let the market trade me. aikido style. trend following style. i love knuckleheads like you who are so ignorant and also so arrogant. please never change. your fake news is terrific, too. love the ignorance. like playing in the special olympics.
China either accumulates a lot of USD or lets it’s currency appreciate. When you’re a foreign country with billions in USD you constantly have to recycle back into forex, your purchasing options are limited. it’s not like China would be allowed to buy McDonalds or acres of Manhattan. They really have no alternative to buying US government debt. I guess they can stealthily accumulate resources in exchange for USD. it would have to be a slow process. I think their long term plan is to allow it to default at some point. They’ll never be able to sell it for what it cost them. Japan is in the same boat. China will more than make up for it when in a couple of decades they control a huge swath of world transport.
I don’t think the US has a defensible position for seizing Russian assets. Russia didn’t invade the US. They did nothing to us. We took it upon ourselves to get involved in Ukraine. Seems we care far more about Ukraine than anyone outside of Ukraine does. We just appoint ourselves world judge and render whatever verdict we want. A good way to make lots of enemies.
china has layed off their USD based holdings. for decades now they have gone around the globe entering into very long term contracts(10 to 100 years in USD) to purchase rights to hard assets like commodities from gold to timber to sudan date plantations. the chinese have layed off the dollars already, like smart bookies. i’m surprised at how many don’t get this play. it’s a net net net good for all involved. jaw jaw and trade trade is better than war war.
Indirect CIPs participants still need to go through SWIFT to complete settlements.
Russian banks could move to a messaging system developed by Russia’s central bank – System for Transfer of Financial Messages (SPFS). Last year, the central bank was reported as saying domestic interbank traffic could easily be transferred to this platform.
BESPOKE, BILATERAL SYSTEMS
A more suitable SWIFT alternative for Russian banks would be to set up bespoke, bilateral systems using phones, faxes or messaging Apps with an overseas partner who would take payment from importers of Russian goods and make payments to exporters to Russia.
Such a system was created by one foreign lender when Iran was cut off from the SWIFT network by sanctions tied to its nuclear programme, a former SWIFT executive familiar with the matter said.
Swift matters but I say Iran set up a Bespoke system and is sharing it. Tons of illegal oil straw buys. Hell in old USSR you could buy a truck of oil for a 100$ at the boarder circa 1990. Syria had similar things going on. So Putin most likely has multiple options. Lets smuggle some Titanium. haha.
Unfortunately for Russia, they don’t have the rubles to fund the infrastructure necessary to create their own system. And just like Germany heading towards WWII, a lot of their best scientists are going to leave the country.
dpy
2 years ago
I understand nowadays the endgame that some western elites hope for re the collapse of Russia and the privitization to themselvse of the natural resources. That game has been around for a long time now. What’s surprising me though is how blatantly they disregard the privations and suffering of their plebs in the manufactured chaos that leads to the endgame. Also surprising how many ideocrats play along with the game without any critical thinking, or again, concern for the fate of the plebs in their countries.
Then again, if you remember the talk about population reduction at their club meetings……..
To add to the population control theme, the elites have access to nice, well equipped underground bunkers, equipped with big screen TV monitors, and a supply of popcorn, with which to sit back and watch the extermination show they will produce up on the surface.
Someone asked a politician some time back, ‘Will the nukes ever be used in war?’ The response,‘That’s what they’re for.’ The defense rests.
Mike 2112
2 years ago
Between this action by the Fed and Trudeau freezing bank accounts w/o due process belonging to peaceful protesters the message is clear to the world that other nations need less dependence on the dollar and individuals need a decentralized currency system. Politically and socially this is a win for crytpo.
Now throw in private corporations from banks to restaurants freezing their dealings with Russia and the need to de-couple from the US to a lesser degree is a no-brainer from a national security point of view for countries around the world.
Not just peaceful protesters, but potentially accounts of those who donated a few toonies to said protesters. The RCMP claimed otherwise, but official testimony didn’t preclude it:
“Conservative MP Philip Lawrence of Ontario pressed Jacques on the matter during the hearing.
“Just to be clear, a financial contribution either through a
crowdsourced platform or directly, could result in their bank account
being frozen?” Lawrence asked.
One has to wonder if the U.S. will be treated in kind when its next unjustified foreign escapade occurs.
Call_Me_Al
TheWindowCleaner
2 years ago
Yes punishing everbody is stupid. Why not do something that is both universally beneficial and selectibly punishing like all sales of petroleum are discounted 50% and the FED will pay the remaining 50% to make the transaction whole…except for petroleum etc. from Russia. You know I’ve followed you since 2007 Mish, and you know the game under the present monetary paradigm very well. Its about time you awakened to the new monetary paradigm however.
That way China can still buy russian oil etc. …but the temptation will be to purchase it elsewhere, and nobody else is stupid enough to have to pay 100% of the going price when they can get oil for 50% off.
Captain Ahab
2 years ago
And gold plummets–down $67 this morning. Gotta wonder who’s playing games here.
My opinion, for what it is worth, manipulation to convey ‘information.’
EGW
2 years ago
Raise your hand if you voted for Biden, now give yourself a good slap across the face. I think it’s fair to say Trump was more competent as a US President than Biden is…as odd as that may sound.
I think you are delusional and should cease smoking/drinking whatever you are imbibing!
Carl_R
2 years ago
Good article, Mish, and I agree. Yet, the market does not (for now) seem to agree. Gold is way down, and Dow futures are way up, and the USD is only down a little.
Dead cat bounce IMHO. It may bounce for a while but other countries will adjust and as Mish as pointed out that is not good long term for the US.
PreCambrian
2 years ago
As usual you are part right. It was foolish to freeze Russia’s reserves at the Fed. Countries and people will eventually start to realize that real things are more valuable than paper. However I think that you are wrong regarding a response to the Russian invasion of Ukraine. Would you rather have a shooting war or an economic war? Just because Russia produces many commodities doesn’t mean that we should allow it to overrun any country at its borders (or perhaps even away from its borders). An effective embargo is the best weapon we can wield. Also it takes time to increase domestic oil production, which had been declining somewhat due to low oil prices and a resulting lower CapEx cycle. Venezuela (and Saudi Arabia) have facilities which can easily increase output. Now the reason that those countries won’t listen to us is another issue. In the long run if the Saudi’s would rather depend on Russia or China for defense of its oil and oil routes that is their decision. I find it somewhat bewildering that the US has frozen Afghan assets when it was Saudi citizens that planned and orchestrated the 9/11 attack with funds originating in Saudi Arabia.
Sometimes you have to understand there is nothing you can do (Russia invading Ukraine being an example) about a given situation in the world and you have to let others work things out even if you don’t like the results.
The reason so many countries aren’t listening to us is because we turn our backs on them in the next minute when we pick sides in some other fight that they are in.
US foreign policy has radically shifted from the early 20th century. Back then we supplied goods to both sides in WWI and even early WW2 because the US remained neutral. Now it picks a side in every fight everywhere so the US is no longer neutral. This means it’s not a good place to be keeping your money, your payment systems or anything else.
One thing to note about Russia so far. They seem to be avoiding making bad long term business decisions. For example 2 of the biggest anti virus companies are Avast and Kaspersky labs. They are on millions if not tens of millions of PCs in the West. Imagine if they suddenly sent an update to everyone and locked out or wiped out their PC. That could happen but it would be business suicide. Instead they continue to provide a very valuable service and when this war eventually ends, people will continue to use those products with confidence. On the other hand, many US tech products are going to be long term dead products (who is going to trust Apple or Google going forward or even say Tesla with their smart cars etc).
Good point about Kaspersky. I had them on my Android phone. Just uninstalled them now. Seems prudent to remove all Russian based apps, especially those with elevated privileges. There are always alternatives.
At the time (circa 9/11), the US had two ‘friends’ in that part of the world (of any consequence); Israel and Saudi Arabia. Shortly after day 1, the US knew the Saudi connection. An attack was on them was not going to happen. Equally, an attack on Afghanistan was not going to happen–the world’s worst terrain, and the world’s best guerilla fighters. Iraq was low-hanging fruit, with high information value.
Pappy Bush kicked Saddam out of Kuwait. War over. Saddam still alive, but a no-fly zone in place (for whatever). Bush jr. said, “Hold my beer and watch this”.
You have no idea what Bush Jr said! Repeating what mass-media morons said at the time is not helpful.
Post 9/11, Iraq was ‘low-hanging’ fruit with a reputation for murdering its own people, making it easy to demonstrate to the rest of the world what will happen if the US is attacked again. It was not about WMD or oil, but sending a message to terrorist-supporting countries. The reason: at the time, the USA lacked a strong defense against terrorism (as demonstrated by 9/11–they walked through Logan with NO security check).
MIC and PNAC. we needed a new enemy after collapse of USSR. jihadis were just barely worse than hells angels. a joke. now we convinced dumb amerikans to hate the russians and chinese. again. MIC and bankers happy. amerikans dumb. they love war. why they vote for war mongers.
Yeah, yeah, yeah. Real things are more valuable but moving real things, like gold for example, is extremely difficult. That is why an electronic system will always needed. And countries/businesses will always gravitate to the system that is most robust and gives them the timely service that they need.
“Freedom” . . .yes we have the “freedom” for little boys to wack off their privates, take hormone blockers and become a “girl”, or have adult men say they are a “woman” and beat all the women in sports.Yeah that’s real freedom there . . .
– no other country pours money into US elections
– no other party takes any foreign money
– there is no other way to launder money than direct donations
The finishing touches have been applied to shape the economy into a completely centrally controlled system, giving new meaning to the phrase “Political Economy.” In this brave new world of Command and Control, the only thing that matters is, the central planner’s agenda.
For analogous purposes, open the history books to around 1917, and the Bolshevik period of the formation of the Soviet Union, but you might also take a peek at the events that took place around 1933 in Germany, just for a contrary perspective.
The Kremlin on Wednesday said that the U.S.has declared an “economic war” on Moscow with its actions in response to the Russian invasion of Ukraine.
The comments by Kremlin spokesman link to thehill.com came after link to thehill.com announced on Tuesday that the U.S. would no longer import Russian oil, link to reuters.com.
March 8 (Reuters) – Chinese companies that defy U.S. restrictions against exporting to Russia may be cut off from American equipment and software they need to make their products, U.S. Commerce Secretary Gina Raimondo told the New York Times.
The U.S. could “essentially shut” down Semiconductor Manufacturing International Corp link to reuters.com or any Chinese companies defying U.S. sanctions by continuing to supply chips and other advanced technology to Russia, Raimondo said in an interview published on Tuesday.
The Federal Reserve is only doing what it did just before and during World War II. During that conflict the Fed cut off the ability of the Axis powers to use their currency reserves in the same manor and made working with Axis banks and companies everywhere in the unoccupied countries “toxic”. It also manipulated the metals and precious metals markets to that end. After the war the Fed reverted to its normal practices. The Fed today is on a war footing and are using the tools it has used before and more to help win it. That’s all.
BESPOKE, BILATERAL SYSTEMS
A more suitable SWIFT alternative for Russian banks would be to set up bespoke, bilateral systems using phones, faxes or messaging Apps with an overseas partner who would take payment from importers of Russian goods and make payments to exporters to Russia.
Such a system was created by one foreign lender when Iran was cut off from the SWIFT network by sanctions tied to its nuclear programme, a former SWIFT executive familiar with the matter said.
“Just to be clear, a financial contribution either through a
crowdsourced platform or directly, could result in their bank account
being frozen?” Lawrence asked.
“Yes,” Jacques answered.”